title: Pragmatic schemas and the selection task: to reason or not to reason.
abstract: Cheng and Holyoak (1985) have proposed that people possess classes of linguistically based schemas that have an internal structure that is determined by pragmatic considerations. They found that when permission schemas ("If you want to do P, then you must do Q") are used in the selection task, the success rate is much superior to what is usually observed. According to Cheng and Holyoak, this is due to the fact that the permission schema is defined by a set of production rules that give the same answers to problems of conditional inference as those of formal logic. In order to test this hypothesis specifically, 160 university students were given one of two tests. The first contained two sets of inferential reasoning tasks, one using a permission schema, the second using a relation of multiple causality. The second test employed the same two conditional relations, but in an appropriate context. The results indicated that subjects did better on the reasoning task with the schema of multiple causality when presented in context, but, as predicted, their performance was much worse on the inferential reasoning task with the permission schema, which generated a higher proportion of logically incorrect responses. These results suggest that contrary to what has been affirmed, permission schemas might not have a logical structure that is equivalent to conditional logic. A second experiment examined selection task performance using the same two relations in context. Performance on the permission schema was superior to that found with the relation of multiple causality. This confirmed previous results indicating that permission schemas do improve selection task performance, but also suggests that this effect is not related to understanding of conditional reasoning.
authors.affiliation: Département de Psychologie, Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada.
authors.forename: H
authors.initials: H
authors.lastname: Markovits
authors.forename: F
authors.initials: F
authors.lastname: Savary
mesh_terms: D000328:Adult; D001288:Attention; D003210:Concept Formation; D006801:Humans; D008128:Logic; D011340:Problem Solving; D012660:Semantics