Multilaboratory evaluation of methods for detecting enteric viruses in soils.
Two candidate methods for the recovery and detection of viruses in soil were subjected to round robin comparative testing by members of the American Society for Testing and Materials D19:24:04:04 Subcommittee Task Group. Selection of the methods, designated "Berg" and "Goyal," was based on results of an initial screening which indicated that both met basic criteria considered essential by the task group. Both methods utilized beef extract solutions to achieve desorption and recovery of viruses from representative soils: a fine sand soil, an organic muck soil, a sandy loam soil, and a clay loam soil. One of the two methods, Goyal, also used a secondary concentration of resulting soil eluants via low-pH organic flocculation to achieve a smaller final assay volume. Evaluation of the two methods was simultaneously performed in replicate by nine different laboratories. Each of the produced samples was divided into portions, and these were respectively subjected to quantitative viral plaque assay by both the individual, termed independent, laboratory which had done the soil processing and a single common reference laboratory, using a single cell line and passage level. The Berg method seemed to produce slightly higher virus recovery values; however, the differences in virus assay titers for samples produced by the two methods were not statistically significant (P less than or equal to 0.05) for any one of the four soils. Despite this lack of a method effect, there was a statistically significant laboratory effect exhibited by assay titers from the independent versus reference laboratories for two of the soils, sandy loam and clay loam.
Hurst
C J
CJ
United States Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati, Ohio 45268.
Schaub
S A
SA
Sobsey
M D
MD
Farrah
S R
SR
Gerba
C P
CP
Rose
J B
JB
Goyal
S M
SM
Larkin
E P
EP
Sullivan
R
R
Tierney
J T
JT
D004770:Enterovirus / Q000302:isolation & purification*; D005069:Evaluation Studies as Topic; D007753:Laboratories; D012722:Sewage; D012988:Soil Microbiology; D014773:Virology / Q000379:methods*
D012722:Sewage