A prospective trial comparing the efficacy and complications of the modified Dornier HM3 and MFL 5000 lithotriptors for solitary renal calculi.
A prospective randomized study of 198 patients was conducted to compare the efficacy of the modified Dornier HM3 lithotriptor to the MFL 5000 lithotriptor. Entrance criteria included solitary stones at any location within the upper collecting system that had not previously been treated with lithotripsy. Following lithotripsy the patients were evaluated by a blinded radiologist with a plain abdominal film, tomograms and renal ultrasound at 1, 4 and 12 weeks. Patients were classified at 12 weeks after lithotripsy as failing treatment if any stone fragments were imaged. Of the patients 170 were available for complete 3-month followup. No statistical or clinical difference in stone-free rates was apparent for calculi in the ureter or renal pelvis in either group. Of patients with lower caliceal stones 80% had no residual fragments visualized at 12 weeks when treated with the modified HM3 device versus 56% with the MFL 5000 lithotriptor (p = 0.05). Treatment time on the MFL 5000 unit was significantly prolonged compared with the modified HM3 device (0.7 hours versus 0.4 hours, respectively) resulting in fewer patients being treated in a given day (p < 0.001). No statistical difference in complication rates could be found between the 2 machines. Steinstrasse were noted in 10% of the patients treated with the modified HM3 device and 6% of the MFL 5000 group. Subcapsular hematomas were noted in 4% of the MFL 5000 treatment arm compared to 1% in the modified HM3 group. Overall, the MFL 5000 lithotriptor was believed to offer no significant clinical advantage over the modified HM3 device in terms of lithotripsy efficacy, although the multifunctional table did offer more versatility for stone treatment. For a busy lithotripsy center, the modified HM3 lithotriptor is still the most efficacious.
Chan
S L
SL
Department of Surgery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Stothers
L
L
Rowley
A
A
Perler
Z
Z
Taylor
W
W
Sullivan
L D
LD
D000328:Adult; D000368:Aged; D000369:Aged, 80 and over; D004867:Equipment Design; D005260:Female; D005500:Follow-Up Studies; D006801:Humans; D007669:Kidney Calculi / Q000628:therapy*; D008096:Lithotripsy / Q000009:adverse effects / Q000295:instrumentation; D008297:Male; D008875:Middle Aged; D011446:Prospective Studies