The Impact of Laparoscopic Surgery on Vaginal Hysterectomy
The development of laparoscopic surgery may be used either to replace (laparoscopic hysterectomy, LH) or to extend the indications (laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy, LAVH) of the vaginal route. A 2-year (March 1991-March 1993) prospective study of the impact of laparoscopic surgery has been carried out by a group of surgeons experienced in both vaginal and laparoscopic surgery. The design of the study protocol was as follows: use the vaginal route whenever possible; select LH in women with very narrow vaginal access or LAVH to improve the feasibility and safety of vaginal hysterectomy in case of adnexal disease; and select laparotomy only when both laparoscopic and vaginal surgery are impossible. Women with genital prolapse or pelvic relaxation were excluded as well as women with invasive malignant disease of the genital tract. Four hundred twenty-eight patients were included. Abdominal hysterectomy was used in only 44 cases (10.3%), including 4 cases of failure of the vaginal technique. Vaginal hysterectomy was completed without laparoscopic assistance in 339 (79.2%) of cases. LAVH was performed in 45 cases (10.5%), LH in 0. Laparoscopic surgery is an efficient modality for the vaginal surgeon in the presence of adnexal disease, but does not replace the less expensive, quicker and probably safer vaginal hysterectomy.
Querleu
D
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Pavillion P. Gelle, 91 Avenue Julien Lagache, Roubaix, France.
Cosson
M
Parmentier
D
Debodinance
P
Crepin
G