Predicting health effects of exposures to compounds with estrogenic activity: methodological issues.
Many substances are active in in vitro tests for estrogenic activity, but data from multigenerational and other toxicity studies are not available for many of those substances. Controversy has arisen, therefore, concerning the likelihood of adverse health effects. Based on a toxic equivalence factor risk assessment approach, some researchers have concluded that exposure to environmental estrogens is not associated with estrogen receptor (ER)-mediated health effects. Their rationale cites the low potency of these compounds in in vitro assays relative to estradiol, and the widespread exposure to pharmaceutical, endogenous, and dietary estrogens. This reasoning relies on two assumptions: that the relative estrogenic potency in in vitro assays is predictive of the relative potency for the most sensitive in vivo estrogenic effect; and that all estrogens act via the same mechanism to produce the most sensitive in vivo estrogenic effect. Experimental data reviewed here suggest that these assumptions may be inappropriate because diversity in both mechanism and effect exists for estrogenic compounds. Examples include variations in ER-ligand binding to estrogen response elements, time course of nuclear ER accumulation, patterns of gene activation, and other mechanistic characteristics that are not reflected in many in vitro assays, but may have significance for ER-mediated in vivo effects. In light of these data, this report identifies emerging methodological issues in risk assessment for estrogenic compounds: the need to address differences in in vivo end points of concern and the associated mechanisms; pharmacokinetics; the crucial role of timing and duration of exposure; interactions; and non-ER-mediated activities of estrogenic compounds.
Rudel
R
R
Silent Spring Institute, Newton, Massachusetts 02158, USA. rudel@silent.shore.net
D000818:Animals; D001943:Breast Neoplasms / Q000209:etiology / Q000378:metabolism; D004353:Drug Evaluation, Preclinical; D004781:Environmental Exposure; D004782:Environmental Health; D004785:Environmental Pollutants / Q000493:pharmacokinetics / Q000633:toxicity*; D004967:Estrogens / Q000378:metabolism; D004968:Estrogens, Non-Steroidal / Q000493:pharmacokinetics / Q000633:toxicity*; D005260:Female; D006801:Humans; D066298:In Vitro Techniques; D007529:Isoflavones; D008297:Male; D048789:Phytoestrogens; D028321:Plant Preparations; D011247:Pregnancy; D011960:Receptors, Estrogen / Q000378:metabolism; D018570:Risk Assessment
D004785:Environmental Pollutants; D004967:Estrogens; D004968:Estrogens, Non-Steroidal; D007529:Isoflavones; D048789:Phytoestrogens; D028321:Plant Preparations; D011960:Receptors, Estrogen