Comparing exemplar-retrieval and decision-bound models of speeded perceptual classification.
The authors compared the exemplar-based random-walk (EBRW) model of Nosofsky and Palmeri (1997) and the decision-bound model (DBM) of Ashby and Maddox (1994; Maddox & Ashby, 1996) on their ability to predict performance in Garner's (1974) speeded classification tasks. A key question was the extent to which the models could predict facilitation in the correlated task and interference in the filtering task, in situations involving integral-dimension stimuli. To obtain rigorous constraints for model evaluation, the goal was to fit the detailed structure of the response time (RT) distribution data associated with each individual stimulus in each task. Both models yielded reasonably good global quantitative fits to the RT distribution and accuracy data. However, the DBM failed to properly characterize the interference effects in the filtering task. Apparently, a fundamental limitation of the DBM is that it predicts that the fastest RTs in the filtering task should be faster than the fastest RTs in the control task, whereas the opposite pattern was observed in our data.
Nosofsky
R M
RM
Department of Psychology, Indiana University, Bloomington 47405, USA. nosofsky@indiana.edu
Palmeri
T J
TJ
D003657:Decision Making; D006801:Humans; D008144:Loudness Perception; D008568:Memory; D010898:Pitch Perception; D011930:Reaction Time