Hypnotics and caffeine as countermeasures for shiftwork-related sleepiness and sleep disturbance.
Hypnotic medication reliably improves sleep during the day, in terms of increasing total sleep time (TST) and reducing awakenings and light sleep. Middle-aged individuals may benefit more than young adults. In addition, the time of day during which sleep is attempted may influence the efficacious dose of short-acting drugs. Available data suggest that improving sleep during the day may improve alertness/performance at night to a mild degree, but significant circadian-related sleepiness remains. Hypnotic medication may help minimize the cumulative effects of sleep loss associated with daytime sleep. Use for more than one week has not been adequately studied; however, as most night and rotating workers' schedules allow for night-time sleep for two or more nights per week, available evidence indicates that hypnotics can be used effectively on an intermittent basis, e.g. for the first 2-4 day-sleep periods of night shifts. Caffeine has been shown to increase alertness and improve psychomotor performance during usual night-shift hours when taken between 22.30 and 01.20 hours. Available data indicate that at approximate dosages of 250-400 mg, the beneficial effects persist until at least 05.30 hours. For most subjects, caffeine taken at the start of the night-shift does not interfere significantly with daytime sleep beginning at 09.00 hours. There is also some evidence that single doses of caffeine at the beginning of a night shift may be more alerting than divided doses. If caffeine is to be used therapeutically, avoidance of social use may be required to avoid tolerance to CNS stimulant effects. Despite the positive results of laboratory research examining hypnotics or caffeine as shiftwork countermeasures, field trials have not been conducted.
Walsh
JK
Sleep Medicine and Research Center, St Luke's HospitaL, St Louis, Missouri, USA.
Muehlbach
MJ
Schweitzer
PK