Cost-minimization analysis: radiation treatment with and without a multi-leaf collimator.
OBJECTIVE
To compare the costs of radiation treatment on a linear accelerator with a multileaf collimator (MLC) versus treatment on a linear accelerator without an MLC. The study was designed to determine whether the increased throughput of fields and decreased block cutting made the MLC cost effective from an institutional perspective.


METHODS
The number of fields, basic treatment equivalent, equivalent simple treatment visits, and blocks were prospectively collected for the four linear accelerators. Building, equipment, staffing, and service costs were all obtained in 1999 Australian dollars from the manufacturers and hospital department heads. The Joint Radiation Oncology Centre at Westmead and Nepean Hospitals, which are Australian public hospitals, runs as one unit, with the same staff, and currently operates five linear accelerators. Currently, four of the linear accelerators are used for general radiotherapy, operating for exactly the same hours; the final machine operates more limited hours and is used for specialized radiotherapy techniques and emergency cases.


RESULTS
The two machines with MLCs, on average, treated 5,169 fields each, while the two machines without MLCs treated 4,543 fields in a 3-month period, a 12% increase in throughput. The two non-MLC machines required 155 premounted trays (PMTs) in total, while the MLC machines required 17 PMTs. Linear accelerators with MLCs were demonstrably more efficient, and while their capital costs were higher, the reduction in labor costs associated with block cutting and, particularly the increased throughput, more than offset these initial costs. The total cost of a radiation field with an MLC was found to be $A101.69 compared to $A106.98 without an MLC. A multiway sensitivity analysis showed the results to be robust. The worst-case scenario was a departmental savings of $A168,000 per year; the best-case scenario was a savings of $A680,000 per year.


CONCLUSIONS
Under the conditions pertaining to the radiation oncology department in this group of hospitals, and in similar departments, the use of an MLC can be justified.
Foroudi
F
F
Joint Radiation Oncology Centre, Westmead and Nepean Hospitals, New South Wales, Australia.
Lapsley
H
H
Manderson
C
C
Yeghiaian-Alvandi
R
R
D001315:Australia; D002201:Capital Expenditures; D003284:Contract Services / Q000191:economics; D003362:Cost-Benefit Analysis; D004389:Durable Medical Equipment / Q000191:economics; D008284:Maintenance and Engineering, Hospital / Q000191:economics; D010315:Particle Accelerators / Q000191:economics* / Q000295:instrumentation; D010561:Personnel Staffing and Scheduling; D011446:Prospective Studies; D011878:Radiotherapy / Q000191:economics* / Q000295:instrumentation