[Effect strength variation in the single group pre-post study design: a critical review].
In Germany, studies in rehabilitation research--in particular evaluation studies and examinations of quality of outcome--have so far mostly been executed according to the uncontrolled one-group pre-post design. Assessment of outcome is usually made by comparing the pre- and post-treatment means of the outcome variables. The pre-post differences are checked, and in case of significance, the results are increasingly presented in form of effect sizes. For this reason, this contribution presents different effect size indices used for the one-group pre-post design--in spite of fundamental doubts which exist in relation to that design due to its limited internal validity. The numerator concerning all effect size indices of the one-group pre-post design is defined as difference between the pre- and post-treatment means, whereas there are different possibilities and recommendations with regard to the denominator and hence the standard deviation that serves as the basis for standardizing the difference of the means. Used above all are standardization oriented towards the standard deviation of the pre-treatment scores, standardization oriented towards the pooled standard deviation of the pre- and post-treatment scores, and standardization oriented towards the standard deviation of the pre-post differences. Two examples are given to demonstrate that the different modes of calculating effect size indices in the one-group pre-post design may lead to very different outcome patterns. Additionally, it is pointed out that effect sizes from the uncontrolled one-group pre-post design generally tend to be higher than effect sizes from studies conducted with control groups. Finally, the pros and cons of the different effect size indices are discussed and recommendations are given.
Maier-Riehle
B
B
Institut für Psychotherapie und medizinische Psychologie, Universität Würzburg. brigitte.maier-riehle@vdr.de
Zwingmann
C
C
D016022:Case-Control Studies; D003627:Data Interpretation, Statistical; D005069:Evaluation Studies as Topic; D005858:Germany; D006801:Humans; D010043:Outcome and Process Assessment, Health Care / Q000379:methods; D012046:Rehabilitation / Q000379:methods*; D012107:Research Design