Are sterile conditions essential for all forms of cutaneous surgery? The case of ritual neonatal circumcision.
BACKGROUND
Many aspects of cutaneous surgical interventions have been perfected, employed, and then scientifically examined. Conversely, ubiquitous, indiscriminate demand for sterile conditions while performing an invasive procedure remains a field devoid of satisfactory critical appraisal.


OBJECTIVE
Ritual neonatal circumcision served as a prototype to assess scientifically the safety of performing a dermatologic intervention under clean, uncontaminated, but nonsterile conditions.


METHODS
Two hundred subjects, mostly neonates, who were unselectively referred for ritual circumcision, served as the study group. The guillotine excisional technique was employed in the community setting under clean, uncontaminated, nonsterile conditions, in line with traditional practice. Follow-up was continued until full recovery.


RESULTS
No wound infections or septic complications were observed in any of the babies at either early (24-36 hours after the procedure) or late follow-up. Many subjects had an exudative discharge at the healing site several days after the procedure. This is a common finding associated with circumcision and was found to be nonindicative of infection.


CONCLUSIONS
This preliminary study suggests that strict sterile conditions are superfluous for ritual neonatal circumcision, and the effort and expense invested in maintaining an aseptic environment for this sort of intervention may not be justified. Further large-scale investigations are warranted to validate these findings and to determine if they can be extrapolated to other patient populations and other types of cutaneous surgery.
Naimer SA
Gush Katif Health Center, Department of Family Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, and Regional Dermatological Center C, Beersheva, Israel.
Trattner A
D002944:Circumcision, Male; D006801:Humans; D007231:Infant, Newborn; D008297:Male; D013242:Sterilization; D013530:Surgical Wound Infection / Q000517:prevention & control*