Development, test reliability and validation of a classification for revision hip arthroplasty.
The objective of the study was to develop a valid and reliable classification system for failed hip arthroplasties. The study uses research principals derived from multi-attribute utility theory and consensus group techniques. The development of the severity measure was done in two phases. Phase I of the study included: (a) questionnaire development, (b) submission of the questionnaire to the respondents, (c) data synthesis of the responses and item reduction, and (d) classification development and inter-observer reliability testing. Phase II included: (a) resubmission of the instrument to the respondents for suggestions/feedback, (b) instrument revision by the co-investigators based on the respondents' second feedback, and (c) inter-observer reliability testing and intraoperative validity testing of the instrument. The questionnaires sought to capture expert opinion as to what clinical determinants obtained preoperatively (during patient interview, physical exam and review of plain radiographs - AP pelvis and hip lateral) that would in their clinical experience reveal intraoperative severity. There was an 80% (16/20) response rate from the outside experts invited to participate in the study. Based on item reduction and test retest analysis, a five-grade radiographic classification for the acetabulum as well as the femur was developed. This system was then reviewed by 13 of the initial outside experts (16, 80%) who participated in the first round. Inter-rater reliability testing of the final format of the classification revealed a weighted kappa statistic value of 0.88 between the two-blinded raters (inter-rater reliability) and 0.87 between the blinded raters and the reference standard (intraoperative validity). We conclude that the study developed a reliable and valid radiographic classification system for failed hip arthroplasty.
Saleh
K J
KJ
Department of Orthopedics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455, USA. saleh002@tc.umn.edu
Holtzman
J
J
Gafni ASaleh
L
L
Jaroszynski
G
G
Wong
P
P
Woodgate
I
I
Davis
A
A
Gross
A E
AE
D019644:Arthroplasty, Replacement, Hip / Q000009:adverse effects / Q000379:methods*; D006801:Humans