[Quality control of spirometric tests used in health surveillance for occupational exposure risk, in the province of Viterbo].
A quality control survey on spirometry assessments carried out in a number of factories in the province of Viterbo (Lazio Region) was made by the Local Health Unit in Viterbo, as required by law 626/94 on the promotion of workers health. The survey concerned 734 measurements concerning the same number of employees from 29 different factories. Each spirometry assessment was repeated in this study according to the quality standards defined in the literature and our own results were compared with the values which had been obtained over one year during the health surveillance program (ASP). A few main functional parameters were considered according to the following criteria: percentage of agreement (tolerance +/- 5%) between the two FVC, FEV1 and FEF25-75 measures or degree of discrepancy; for FEV1/FVC ratio, the occurrence of < 70 (suggestive of an obstructive lesion) and > 90 values (reflecting poor reliability in the measurement of the lung volumes) in the two sets of data. Further criteria concerned the comparison of the height of the individuals (tolerance range +/- 1 cm), and the comparison of the overall spirometry rating expressed as the number of tests rated normal or abnormal (during the first assessment as compared to the second). The results show poor agreement (11.4%) for FVC with as many as 85.8% underestimated values; 30.1% agreement and 64.2% underestimate for FEV1; 17% agreement and 53.5% overestimate for FEF25-75. There were 6.5% fewer < 70 FEV1/FVC ratios, and 18.3% more > 90 ratios in the tests carried out in the factories as compared to our own. There was 32.9% agreement on the height, with overestimation in 63.7% of the cases. There were 12.3% "false abnormal" and 2.6% "false normal" results in the overall rating of the spirometry (as carried out by the factories compared to our own). In conclusion, the survey revealed a trend in the measurements carried out by the factories to underestimate the volumes, overestimate the flows, improperly select the theoretical reference values because of a mistake in measuring the height, to overestimate restrictive abnormalities, and underestimate the obstructive ones.
Valenti
E
E
Servizio di Prevenzione, Igiene e Sicurezza nei Luoghi di Lavoro, A.S.L. Viterbo, Via Ferretti 169, 01033 Civita Castellana. spisllcc@tin.it
Manzari
G
G
De Angelis
V
V
Ercolani
S
S
Liberati
A
A
Capitta
C
C
Mancini
G
G
Scrocchia
I
I
Quercia
A
A
D000328:Adult; D005541:Forced Expiratory Volume; D006801:Humans; D007558:Italy; D016273:Occupational Exposure; D011159:Population Surveillance; D011786:Quality Control; D013147:Spirometry / Q000592:standards*