Triage decisions of prehospital emergency health care providers, using a multiple casualty scenario paper exercise.
OBJECTIVE
To examine the accuracy of theoretical triage decision making among emergency prehospital health care professionals, using a multiple casualty paper exercise.


METHODS
A standardised 20 casualty paper exercise requiring each casualty to be prioritised for treatment was given to 100 doctors, 59 nurses, and 74 ambulance paramedics who could potentially be involved at the scene of a multiple casualty incident. Each paper was scored using the triage sieve algorithm. The paper contained descriptions of two casualties regarded as dead, six priority 1 casualties, six priority 2 casualties, and six priority 3 casualties.


RESULTS
There was no significant difference in the scores received by both doctors and nurses, but paramedics did significantly less well than both nurses and doctors (p<0.05) However, the actual difference in mean scores is only just over 1; both doctors and nurses had a mean score of 13.03 and paramedics a mean score of 11.83. All professional groups tended to over triage patients. While there was no significant difference between doctors and nurses there was a significant difference (p<0.001) between paramedics and both doctors and nurses.


CONCLUSIONS
There is little difference in the accuracy of triage decision making between the professional groups, with doctors and nurses scoring marginally better than paramedics. The rates of over triage are high posing the risk of overwhelming available resources further. Under triage rates are also high, with potentially life threatening conditions going unrecognised. However, some margin of error may be accounted for by the untested validity of the triage sieve methodology.
Kilner
T
T
The University of Birmingham, School of Health Sciences, The Medical School, Edgbaston, Birmingham, UK. t.m.kilner@bham.ac.uk
D000328:Adult; D003657:Decision Making; D004632:Emergency Medical Services / Q000706:statistics & numerical data; D004634:Emergency Medical Technicians; D006801:Humans; D009726:Nurses; D010820:Physicians; D014218:Triage; D006113:United Kingdom; D000078329:Workforce