Pro/con ethics debate: is nonheart-beating organ donation ethically acceptable?
This pro/con debate explores the ethical issues surrounding nonheart-beating organ donation (NHBD), a source of considerable controversy. It is estimated that NHBD can increase the number of organs available for transplant by 25% at a time of great need. However, should NHBD be ethically acceptable? In support of NHBD, it may be acceptable practice if there is a separation of the rationale to withdraw life support/to withhold cardiopulmonary resuscitation from the decision to recover organs, if no conflicts of interest exist, if a waiting time precluding spontaneous return of circulation is included, and if NHBD conforms to a standardized protocol. Against NHBD, there are questions regarding the ambiguity and cultural perspectives of death, regarding whether a separation of rationale between withdrawal and donation is sufficient to preclude conflicts of interest, and regarding whether variable protocols arise that subordinate the patient to the goal of donation. Such concerns suggest NHBD may damage the trust in patient-physician relationships and may adversely affect organ donation rates.
Whetstine
Leslie
L
Duquesne University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA.
Bowman
Kerry
K
Hawryluck
Laura
L
D004992:Ethics, Medical; D006323:Heart Arrest; D006801:Humans; D014019:Tissue Donors; D020858:Tissue and Organ Harvesting / Q000941:ethics* / Q000379:methods*