A prospective randomized trial evaluating tissue effects of finasteride therapy in benign prostatic hyperplasia.
Finasteride is widely used for the treatment of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). Its therapeutic efficacy is believed to be mediated through selective inhibition of prostatic 5alpha-reductase (type II). This prospective, controlled, randomized study examines various relationships between changes in tissue 5alpha-reductase isozyme activity, epithelial proliferative index and morphology in men with BPH treated with finasteride for 6 months, and correlates these with clinical response. Thirty-one patients presenting with symptomatic bladder outflow obstruction were prospectively randomized to receive either finasteride or placebo (2:1) for 24 weeks. Of these, 27 men aged 55-80 y (median 69 y) completed the study, including 18 patients on treatment. Symptom score determination, uroflow and prostate volume were assessed at baseline and end of study. Prostatic tissue was obtained by ultrasound-guided needle biopsy at baseline and by transurethral resection (TURP) at end of study for biochemical and morphometric analysis. Epithelial proliferation was examined quantitatively in the resected tissue using MIB-1 antibody to Ki-67 and counting the percentage of positively staining cells. Type II 5alpha-reductase activity was strongly inhibited by finasteride in resected BPH tissue, with over 100-fold decrease in V(max) (P=0.001), whereas the type I isozyme was inhibited 5-fold (P=0.005). Selective inhibition of type II 5alpha-reductase was demonstrated in all treated patients. No significant difference in epithelial proliferation was observed between the finasteride and placebo groups. Epithelial proliferation was, however, greater in prostatic tissue with histological manifestation of inflammation (2.02% vs 0.89%, P=0.001). Positive correlation between the total epithelial volume and the ratio of transition zone volume/total prostate volume was observed in the placebo group (r=0.834), whereas there was no such correlation in men taking finasteride (r=-0.300), consistent with a reduction in epithelial content in the treatment group. Improvement in uroflow and reduction in prostatic volume in patients treated with finasteride did not reach statistical significance. This study shows that finasteride causes inhibition of 5alpha-reductase activity in human BPH tissue with selectivity for the type II isozyme. In spite of this, no significant effects in epithelial proliferation or tissue morphology were demonstrated. The presence of inflammation was, however, associated with significantly greater proliferative activity. The power of this study was limited by the small number of recruited patients, and a larger study would be required for further investigation of morphological changes induced by finasteride in BPH tissue and their biochemical basis.
Feneley
M R
MR
St Bartholomew's Hospital, London, UK.
Span
P N
PN
Schalken
J A
JA
Harper
M
M
Griffiths
K
K
Holmes
K
K
Kirby
R S
RS