Are our impressions of allergy test performances correct?
BACKGROUND
The clinical diagnosis is often subjective and susceptible to bias, yet it is the primary standard by which diagnostic tests are judged. Consequently, our opinions regarding various diagnostic tests may not be entirely accurate.


OBJECTIVE
To investigate the accuracy of the clinical history compared with concordant skin and quantitative specific IgE (s-IgE) measurements.


METHODS
Consecutive, consenting patients (N = 152) at 2 different allergy centers were examined by history and physical examination (HPE) alone to determine their sensitivity to 7 common allergens. Results were classified as positive, negative, or indeterminate. The HPE results were then compared to concordant skin prick testing (SPT) and s-IgE measurements and to quantitative IgE antibody measurements with and without knowledge of the SPT results.


RESULTS
Diagnosis by HPE deviated considerably from concordant SPT and s-IgE results. This deviation differed between allergists and allergens, reflecting a positive HPE bias that averaged 22%. Seventy-six percent of the HPE results judged indeterminate were resolved as negative. Using additional information from the quantification of s-IgE antibodies, considerable differences between the sites in the level of s-IgE associated with a positive HPE result with and without SPT results were observed.


CONCLUSIONS
Relative to the SPT and quantification of s-IgE antibodies, the diagnosis by HPE alone to common allergens is not consistent. Discrepancies were dependent on both allergen and allergist. The quantitative s-IgE data revealed that allergists use available information from the HPE and SPT differently. Since the HPE is the primary standard used in judging test efficacy (sensitivity and specificity), our current impressions of test performances are not likely to be accurate.
Williams
P Brock
PB
University of Missouri Medical School, Kansas City, Missouri, USA. pbrockwil@aol.com
Ahlstedt
Staffan
S
Barnes
James H
JH
Söderström
Lars
L
Portnoy
Jay
J
D000293:Adolescent; D000485:Allergens; D002648:Child; D005188:False Negative Reactions; D005189:False Positive Reactions; D005260:Female; D006801:Humans; D006967:Hypersensitivity / Q000097:blood / Q000175:diagnosis*; D007073:Immunoglobulin E / Q000097:blood*; D008297:Male; D008487:Medical History Taking / Q000592:standards*; D011237:Predictive Value of Tests; D012882:Skin Tests / Q000592:standards*
D000485:Allergens; D007073:Immunoglobulin E