A comparison of methods used to enumerate Escherichia coli in conventionally treated sewage sludge.
OBJECTIVE
This study examined the suitability of three analytical methods for isolating and enumerating Escherichia coli from conventionally treated sewage sludge.


RESULTS
Crude sewage, mesophilic anaerobic digested (MAD) sludge, and final product sludge samples were taken from six sewage treatment works for analysis. Two of the three methods tested were membrane filtration techniques, utilizing chromogenic E. coli/coliform (CEC) media and membrane-lactose glucuronide agar (MLGA); the third method was a most probable number (MPN) technique utilizing Colilert in Quantitray 2000 (Idexx). The methods were evaluated for variation, consistency, false-positive and false-negative results, as well as method correlation. The methods gave good and consistent recovery of E. coli for a range of conventionally treated sewage matrices. All of the methods had a false-positive rate of <3%, although MLGA had a high false-negative rate (35.5%) compared with Colilert (3.81%) and the CEC method (6.75%). This resulted in slightly lower presumptive counts but comparable numbers of confirmed counts.


CONCLUSIONS
The three detection methods tested, chromogenic, MLGA and Colilert gave comparable recoveries, and did not vary by greater than one order of magnitude (1 log).


CONCLUSIONS
Forthcoming revisions to the Use of Sludge in Agriculture Regulations (1989) will categorize sewage sludge as untreated, conventionally treated or enhanced treated in accordance to microbiological standards. The standard will be based upon numbers of E. coli removed through the sludge treatment process and the numbers remaining in the final product. It is recommended that the Colilert 2000 (Idexx, Westbrook, Maine) and CEC methods would be equally suitable to assess the reduction of indigenous E. coli in conventionally treated sludges, and that MLGA be used with follow-up confirmatory testing.
Eccles
J P
JP
Thames Water, Development Microbiology Laboratories, Spencer House, Reading, Berkshire, UK. jason.eccles@thameswater.co.uk
Searle
R
R
Holt
D
D
Dennis
P J
PJ
D001431:Bacteriological Techniques / Q000379:methods; D015169:Colony Count, Microbial / Q000379:methods; D003470:Culture Media; D004926:Escherichia coli / Q000302:isolation & purification*; D005188:False Negative Reactions; D005189:False Positive Reactions; D005374:Filtration; D015203:Reproducibility of Results; D012722:Sewage / Q000382:microbiology*
D003470:Culture Media; D012722:Sewage