Forest health surveys--a critique.
Surveys of forest health, as presently undertaken, provide information on the general condition of forests. They integrate the effects of all factors, biotic and abiotic, of which pollution is but one, that affect trees. Most surveys are based on the assessment of crown density and crown discoloration. These assessments are subjective and serious errors can occur. In some cases, the sampling design that has been adopted is not the most suitable for the forest area under investigation. The blanket application of a systematic sampling design based on a 16 by 16 km grid is particularly questionable in view of the variation in the nature of Europe's forests. Comparisons, either between regions or through time, may or may not be valid, depending on how the surveys are conducted. Although much progress has been made, standardisation within Europe has not yet been achieved and it is therefore difficult to make comparisons between the results obtained by different countries.
Innes
J L
JL
Forestry Commission, Forest Research Station, Alice Holt Lodge, Wrecclesham, Farnham, Surrey GU10 4LH, UK.