Biomechanical evaluation of fixation techniques for bridging segmental mandibular defects.
OBJECTIVE
To compare biomechanical properties of currently available plating systems used to reconstruct segmental mandibular defects.


METHODS
Controlled in vitro investigation.


METHODS
Academic medical center laboratory.


METHODS
Thirty-two polyurethane mandibles were equally divided among 4 groups: mandibles with a 4-cm lateral segmental defect that was bridged with a (1) 3.0-mm locking-screw reconstruction plate, (2) 2.4-mm low-profile reconstruction plate, or (3) 2.4-mm reconstruction plate and (4) uncut (control) mandibles. All plates were contoured and secured to the synthetic mandibles with 4 bicortical screws on either side of the defect. Three constructs from each group were subjected to contralateral-molar single-load-to-failure testing. Mean yield displacement, yield load, and bending stiffness were quantified and compared among the 4 groups. The single-load-to-failure data were used to establish conditions for fatigue testing; such testing was then performed on the remaining 5 samples in each group. Mean cycles to failure were measured and compared among the 4 groups.


RESULTS
Mean yield displacement, yield load, and bending stiffness were comparable among the plated groups. Both the 3.0-mm locking-screw and 2.4-mm low-profile reconstruction plate designs withstood 1580 and 1124 times more cycles to failure, respectively (P = .005), than did the control group. The other reconstruction plate was also superior to the unplated controls, offering an 865-fold improvement.


CONCLUSIONS
All 3 mandibular fixation device systems tested produce comparable levels of single load to failure biomechanical integrity; however, the higher-profile plating system design offered slightly superior fatigue performance. No differences in performance were observed between the locking and nonlocking designs; neither failed at the screw-substrate interface.
Doty
Jonathan M
JM
Division of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Kentucky Medical Center, Lexington, USA.
Pienkowski
David
D
Goltz
Michele
M
Haug
Richard H
RH
Valentino
Joseph
J
Arosarena
Oneida A
OA
D001696:Biomechanical Phenomena; D006801:Humans; D008334:Mandible / Q000601:surgery*; D008341:Mandibular Prosthesis; D011140:Polyurethanes; D011474:Prosthesis Design
D011140:Polyurethanes