Asymmetry in host and parasitoid diffuse coevolution: when the red queen has to keep a finger in more than one pie.
BACKGROUND: Coevolution between pairs of antagonistic species is generally considered an endless "arms race" between attack and defense traits to counteract the adaptive responses of the other species. PRESENTATION OF THE HYPOTHESIS: When more than two species are involved, diffuse coevolution of hosts and parasitoids could be asymmetric because consumers can choose their prey whereas preys do not choose their predator. This asymmetry may lead to differences in the rate of evolution of the antagonistic species in response to selection. The more long-standing the coevolution of a given pair of antagonistic populations, the higher should be the fitness advantage for the consumer. Therefore, the main prediction of the hypothesis is that the consumer trophic level is more likely to win the coevolution race. TESTING THE HYPOTHESIS: We propose testing the asymmetry hypothesis by focusing on the tritrophic system plant/aphid/aphid parasitoid. The analysis of the genetic variability in the virulence of several parasitoid populations and in the defenses of several aphid species or several clones of the same aphid species could be compared. Moreover, the analysis of the neutral population genetic structure of the parasitoid as a function of the aphid host, the plant host and geographic isolation may complement the detection of differences between host and parasitoid trophic specialization. IMPLICATIONS OF THE HYPOTHESIS: Genetic structures induced by the arms race between antagonistic species may be disturbed by asymmetry in coevolution, producing neither rare genotype advantages nor coevolutionary hotspots. Thus this hypothesis profoundly changes our understanding of coevolution and may have important implications in terms of pest management.
Lapchin
Laurent
L
"Biologie des Populations en Interaction", UMR 1112 "Réponse des Organismes aux Stress Environnementaux", Inra/Unsa, 400 route des Chappes, BP167 06903 Sophia-Antipolis cedex, France. lapchin@antibes.inra.fr.
Guillemaud
Thomas
T
J Theor Biol. 2000 Feb 21;202(4):283-304
10666361
Nature. 2000 Jun 8;405(6787):679-81
10864323
Parasitol Today. 2000 Dec;16(12):506-8
11121843
Immunogenetics. 2001;52(3-4):157-64
11220617
Evolution. 2001 Jun;55(6):1146-52
11475050
Heredity (Edinb). 2003 Jan;90(1):84-9
12522430
J Evol Biol. 2003 Nov;16(6):1319-27
14640423
Annu Rev Phytopathol. 1996;34:29-50
15012533
Am Nat. 2002 Aug;160(2):245-54
18707490
Evolution. 1995 Jun;49(3):427-438
28565087
Evolution. 1998 Aug;52(4):1057-1066
28565221
Evolution. 1999 Oct;53(5):1435-1445
28565548
Am Nat. 1999 May;153(S5):S61-S74
29578778
Parasitology. 1998;116 Suppl:S29-45
9695108