Ethical and legal issues in non-heart-beating organ donation.
Procurement of kidneys and livers from non-heart-beating donors (NHBDs) raises ethical and legal issues that need to be considered carefully before wider use of these donors. Although NHBDs were used in kidney transplantation as early as the 1960s, retrieval of these organs is by no means universally accepted today. From a medical point of view, these organs have long been considered "marginal" because the majority show delayed or impaired graft function. Legal problems include determination of death by cardiopulmonary criteria, the issue of proper consent, and the use of organ preservation measures. Among ethical issues raised are the observance of the Dead-donor Rule, the decision-making surrounding resuscitation, the withdrawal of life-support, the respect for a dying patient and the dead body, as well as proper information to and guidance for the family. In the Netherlands NHB donation was pioneered in the Maastricht Medical Center in 1980s. Today, all seven transplant centers retrieve and transplant organs from these donors, and NHBDs have become an important source of transplantable kidneys and livers. Recent legislation in the Netherlands also supports the use of NHBDs by making possible the use of organ preservation measures after circulatory arrest, even in the absence of family consent. As a result, one of every three kidneys transplanted in the Netherlands in 2004 was obtained from a NHBD. In this study, Dutch NHBD protocols, practice, and results are analyzed and compared with international practices.
Bos
M A
MA
Health Council of the Netherlands, Eurotransplant Ethics Committee, and Dutch Transplant Foundation, The Hague, Netherlands. mike.bos@gr.nl
D005190:Family; D006323:Heart Arrest; D006801:Humans; D007258:Informed Consent; D007668:Kidney; D009426:Netherlands; D014019:Tissue Donors / Q000941:ethics*; D009927:Tissue and Organ Procurement / Q000941:ethics* / Q000331:legislation & jurisprudence*