Eggs forever?
A group of scientists from Harvard Medical School (Johnson et al., 2004) claims to have "established the existence of proliferative germ cells that sustain oocyte and follicle production in the postnatal mammalian ovary," expressing no doubts about their methods, results and conclusion. Johnson et al. based their conclusions of oocyte and follicular renewal from existing germline stem cells (GSC) in the postnatal mouse ovary on three types of observations: (1) A claimed discordance in follicle loss versus follicle atresia in the neonatal period and in the following pubertal and adult period; (2) immunohistochemical detection of proliferating GSC with meiotic capacity using combined markers for meiosis, germline, and mitosis; and (3) neo-folliculogenesis in ovarian chimeric grafting experiments with adult mice. Oogenesis is the process that transforms the proliferative oogonium into an oocyte through meiosis, followed by folliculogenesis and follicular and oocyte maturation. The most crucial part in producing a functional oocyte is firstly, initiation and completion of the first meiotic prophase, and secondly, enclosure of the resulting diplotene oocyte in a follicle. Neither of these two events has been shown to take place in Johnson et al.'s study of the postnatal mouse ovary. We hereby address the observations underpinning their hypothesis and conclude that it is premature to replace the paradigm that adult mammalian neo-oogenesis/folliculogenesis does not take place.
Byskov
Anne Grete
AG
Laboratory of Reproductive Biology, Juliane Marie Centre, Rigshospital, Copenhagen, Denmark. agb.lrb@rh.dk
Faddy
Malcolm J
MJ
Lemmen
Josephine G
JG
Andersen
Claus Yding
CY
D000818:Animals; D002454:Cell Differentiation; D005260:Female; D005496:Follicular Atresia / Q000502:physiology; D006801:Humans; D008540:Meiosis; D051379:Mice; D008810:Mice, Inbred C57BL; D009865:Oocytes / Q000166:cytology*; D010053:Ovary / Q000033:anatomy & histology; D010063:Ovum / Q000166:cytology*