Oxygenation is not improved by partial liquid high frequency ventilation using a high lung volume strategy. An experimental study.
OBJECTIVE
To investigate the effect on oxygenation and lung damage of partial perfluorocarbon liquid high frequency oscillatory ventilation (PL-HFOV) versus high frequency oscillatory ventilation (HFOV) alone, in rabbits with acute lung injury, using high lung volume strategy HFOV.


METHODS
Twelve adult New Zealand white rabbits were initially ventilated with HFOV after anaesthesia, sedation and paralysis. After induction of lung injury with saline lavage, all animals received a single sigh breath of 30 cmH(2)O for 30 seconds. They were then allocated to receive either HFOV alone (n = 6) or PL-HFOV (n = 6). Arterial blood gases were taken pre- and post-lavage and then hourly for 5 hours. The oxygenation index (OI, in cmH(2)O/mmHg) was calculated using the formula: OI = (MAP x F(I)O(2) x 100) / PaO(2). The lungs were then removed for histological examination to score lung injury.


RESULTS
Two rabbits died in the PL-HFOV group and none in the HFOV group, p = 0.45 (Fisher's exact test). At one hour the oxygenation index (OI) was 4.5 in the HFOV group and 6.6 in the PL-HFOV group, p = 0.49 and the PaO(2) was 374 mmHg in the HFOV group and 311 mmHg in the PL-HFOV group, p = 0.39. Average OI over the first three hours was 3.6 in the HFOV group and 5.0 in the PL-HFOV group, p = 0.27 and the PaO(2) was 404 mmHg in the HFOV group and 337 mmHg in the PL-HFOV group, p = 0.12. The lung histology damage score was 2.33 in the HFOV group and 2.50 in the PL-HFOV group, p = 0.83.


CONCLUSIONS
In this model of acute lung injury, using a high volume HFOV strategy to optimise lung recruitment, PL-HFOV did not result in any further improvement in oxygenation when compared with HFOV alone. The question of safety with PL-HFOV remains.
Davies
M W
MW
Division of Neonatal Services, Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria.
Stewart
M J
MJ
Souriel
M
M
Chavasse
R
R
Butt
W
W