An empirical analysis of cost outcomes of the Texas Medication Algorithm Project.
OBJECTIVE
Disease management systems that incorporate medication algorithms have been proposed as cost-effective means to offer optimal treatment for patients with severe and chronic mental illnesses. The Texas Medication Algorithm Project was designed to compare health care costs and clinical outcomes between patients who received algorithm-guided medication management or usual care in 19 public mental health clinics.


METHODS
This longitudinal cohort study for patients with major depression (N=350), bipolar disorder (N=267), and schizophrenia (N=309) applied a multi-part declining-effects cost model. Outcomes were assessed by the Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology and the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale.


RESULTS
Compared with patients in usual care, patients in algorithm-based care incurred higher medication costs and had more frequent physician visits, although these differences often became smaller with time. For major depression, algorithm-based care achieved better outcomes sustainable with time but at higher agency and non-agency costs (mixed cost-effective). For bipolar disorder, patients in algorithm-based management achieved better outcomes at lower agency costs (cost-effective). For schizophrenia, patients in algorithm-based care achieved better outcomes that diminished with time, with no detectable difference in health care costs (cost-effective).


CONCLUSIONS
Cost outcomes of algorithm-based care and usual care varied by disorder and over time. For bipolar disorder and schizophrenia, algorithm-based care improved outcomes without higher costs for health care services. For major depression, substantively better and sustained outcomes were obtained but at greater costs.
Kashner
T Michael
TM
Department of Psychiatry at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX 75390-9086, USA. michael.kashner@utsouthwestern.edu
Rush
A John
AJ
Crismon
M Lynn
ML
Toprac
Marcia
M
Carmody
Thomas J
TJ
Miller
Alexander L
AL
Trivedi
Madhukar H
MH
Wicker
Annie
A
Suppes
Trisha
T