[Retraining between months 4 and 6 after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring graft: comparison between cycling and running with an untrained operated subject group].
OBJECTIVE
To study the effect of cycling or running retraining between 4 and 6 months after patients underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring grafting (Semitendinosus-Gracilis) compared with that in patients who had the same surgery but were untrained.


METHODS
Patients who had undergone surgery for an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction by the same surgeon who used hamstring grafting were included if they were free of knee pain 4 months after the surgery. After giving consent, patients were randomized to receive controlled retraining (cycling or running 3 times a week) or not. The effect of retraining was measured by the evolution of the knee isokinetic peak torque at 60 degrees/s and 180 degrees/s 6 months after surgery.


RESULTS
Fifteen patients were retrained with cycling (GI), 17 with running (GII) and 15 patients did not retrain (GIII). Before retraining, the 3 groups had the same peak torque deficit, measured at an angular speed of 60 degrees/s and 180 degrees/s, for knee extensors (GI: 33+/-11% and 27+/-8%; GII: 30+/-13% and 24+/-10%; GIII: 31+/-15% and 24+/-13%, respectively) and knee flexors (GI: 26+/-11% and 20+/-13%; GII: 20+/-14% and 17+/-13%; GIII: 19+/-15% and 14+/-15%, respectively). After retraining, progress measured at 60 degrees /s of knee extensors and flexors on the operated knees was 18+/-9% and 16+/-10% for GI, 16+/-9% and 11+/-11% for GII and 12+/-15% and 8+/-12 for GIII, respectively. Progress measured at 180 degrees /s followed the same evolution. After comparison of the 3 groups, any significant difference was put in relief according to the type of retraining.


CONCLUSIONS
Retraining after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is necessary for patients to practice their previous sport. In our study, aerobic cycling or running between 4 and 6 months after surgery did not improve peak torque in the operated knee extensors and flexors. However, these 2 types of retraining are well-tolerated.
Dauty
M
M
Pôle de MPR et médecine du sport, hôpital Saint-Jacques, CHU de Nantes, 44035 Nantes cedex 01, France. marc.dauty@chu-nantes.fr
Huguet
D
D
Tortellier
L
L
Potiron-Josse
M
M
Dubois
C
C