title: Detecting (trans)gene flow to landraces in centers of crop origin: lessons from the case of maize in Mexico.
abstract: There is much discussion of the probability of transgene flow from transgenic crop varieties to landraces and wild relatives in centers of origin or diversity, and its genetic, ecological, and social consequences. Without costly research on the variables determining gene flow, research on transgene frequencies in landrace (or wild relative) populations can be valuable for understanding transgene flow and its effects. Minimal research requirements include (1) understanding how farmer practices and seed systems affect landrace populations, (2) sampling to optimize Ne/n (effective/census population size), (3) minimizing variance at all levels sampled, and (4) using Ne to calculate binomial probabilities for transgene frequencies. A key case is maize in Mexico. Two peer-reviewed papers, based on landrace samples from the Sierra Juárez region of Oaxaca, Mexico, reached seemingly conflicting conclusions: transgenes are present (Quist and Chapela, 2001, Nature 414: 541-543; 2002, Nature 416: 602) or "detectable transgenes" are absent (Ortiz-García et al., 2005, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102: 12338-12343 and 18242). We analyzed these papers using information on Oaxacan maize seed systems and estimates of Ne. We conclude that if Quist and Chapela's results showing presence are accepted, Ortiz-García et al.'s conclusions of no evidence of transgenes at detectable levels or for their introgression into maize landraces in the Sierra de Juárez of Oaxaca are not scientifically justified. This is because their samples are not representative, and their statistical analysis is inconclusive due to using n instead of Ne. Using estimates of Ne based on Ortiz-García et al.'s n, we estimate that transgenes could be present in maize landraces in the Sierra Juárez region at frequencies of approximately 1-4%, and are more likely to be present in the 90% of Oaxacan landrace area that is not mountainous. Thus, we have no scientific evidence of maize transgene presence or absence in recent years in Mexico, Oaxaca State, or the Sierra Juárez region.
authors.affiliation: Environmental Studies Program, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106-4160, USA. cleveland@es.ucsb.edu
authors.forename: David A
authors.initials: DA
authors.lastname: Cleveland
authors.forename: Daniela
authors.initials: D
authors.lastname: Soleri
authors.forename: Flavio Aragón
authors.initials: FA
authors.lastname: Cuevas
authors.forename: José
authors.initials: J
authors.lastname: Crossa
authors.forename: Paul
authors.initials: P
authors.lastname: Gepts
mesh_terms: D018556:Crops, Agricultural / Q000235:genetics; D003627:Data Interpretation, Statistical; D051456:Gene Flow; D008800:Mexico; D030821:Plants, Genetically Modified; D011156:Population Density; D012639:Seeds / Q000235:genetics; D003313:Zea mays / Q000235:genetics*