Clinical evaluation of a newly designed nasogastric enteral feeding tube.
Concerned with reports in the literature of a rising incidence of enteral feeding tube clogging, we initiated a design programme in an attempt to improve the clinical efficacy of nasogastric and nasoenteric enteral feeding tubes. Tube design has been based on a remodelling of the outflow part of a polyurethane feeding tube previously developed in our unit. The tip of the newly designed 8F enteral feeding tube is shorter in length with a rounded end to minimize discomfort during intubation. The port itself incorporates a tapered outflow design with the side walls now extending below the mid-point of the internal flow lumen resulting in a 28% increase in port area compared to the equivalent and originally designed tube. The performance of the newly designed polyurethane feeding tube was assessed under controlled trial conditions using as references two widely used 8F polyurethane nasogastric feeding tubes whose design has been based on different principles (Flexiflo, weighted tip, open-ended with two side ports; Freka, occluded tip, two simple large side ports). Eighty-eight of 90 patients entered into the study were successfully intubated with no significant differences being noted in intubation times in the three groups. Significantly less discomfort occurred during intubation of patients with the Radius tube as compared to the Freka tube (P < 0.05). Although there were no clear differences between the Flexiflo and Freka tubes either in regard to the number of attempts required for intubation or aspiration or discomfort during intubation or ease of aspiration, fewer attempts at insertion and aspiration were needed and intubation and aspiration were easier for patients randomised to the Radius group than those to the Flexiflo and Freka groups (P < 0.05). We conclude that the clinical performance of the newly designed Radius enteral feeding tube compares favourably with that of the reference tubes. Only one of the new tubes (3.3%) blocked during the course of the study. High rates of non-elective extubation were observed in the three study groups (Radius 80.0%, Flexiflo 73.3%, Freka 73.3%). Design modifications are unlikely to influence non-elective nasogastric feeding tube extubation rates which remain a major clinical problem.
Silk
D B
DB
Department of Gastroenterology & Nutrition, Central Middlesex Hospital NHS Trust, Acton Lane, London NW10 7NS, UK.
Bray
M J
MJ
Keele
A M
AM
Walters
E R
ER
Duncan
H D
HD