[There is a difference between scientific hypothesis and the "phylogenetic presumption" by Rasnitsyn (concerning the paper by I.Ia. Pavlinov, 2005. J. Gen. Biology. V. 66. No 5)].
The arguments by Pavlinov against my critical analysis of the concept of the "phylogenetic presumptions" proposed by Rasnitsyn are briefly discussed. It is proved that these arguments are invalid because they are based on the substitution of terms. Instead of the term "phylogenetic presumption" introduced by Rasnitsyn just as an analogue of the presumption of innocence in jurisprudence, Pavlinov considers the presumption in the wider understanding, i.e. as a "preliminary statement".
Pesenko
Iu A
IuA
D001695:Biology / Q000379:methods*; D010802:Phylogeny; D009626:Terminology as Topic