Reproducibility of binary-mixture toxicity studies.
Binary-mixture studies often are conducted with the aim of elucidating the effect of one specific chemical on the biological action of another. The results can be interpreted in relation to reference models by the use of response-surface analyses and isobolograms. The amount of data needed for these analyses is, however, extensive, and the experiments therefore rarely are repeated. In the present study, we investigate the reproducibility of isobole shapes of binary-mixture toxicity experiments in terms of deviation from the reference model of concentration addition (CA), dose-level dependence, and isobole asymmetry. We use data from four herbicide mixtures tested in three to five independent experiments on the aquatic test plant Lemna minor and the terrestrial plant Tripleurospermum inodorum. The results showed that the variation both within and among experiments was approximately half the size for the aquatic test system compared to the terrestrial system. As a consequence, a consistent deviation from CA could be obtained in three of four herbicide mixtures for L. minor, whereas this was only the case for one or two of the herbicide mixtures tested on T. inodorum. For one mixture on T. inodorum, both CA synergism and antagonism were detected. Dose-dependent effects could not be repeated consistently, just as the asymmetry found in some isoboles could not. The study emphasizes the importance of repeating mixture toxicity experiments, especially for test systems with large variability, and using caution when drawing biological conclusions from the test results.
Cedergreen
Nina
N
Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University (KVL), Institute of Agricultural Sciences, Højbakkegård Allé 13, 2630 Taastrup, Denmark. ncf@kvl.dk
Kudsk
Per
P
Mathiassen
Solvejg Kopp
SK
Sørensen
Helle
H
Streibig
Jens Carl
JC
D010944:Plants / Q000187:drug effects; D015203:Reproducibility of Results; D018675:Toxicity Tests