title: Addressing the threat of evidence-based practice to qualitative inquiry through increasing attention to quality: a discussion paper.
abstract: The current evidence-based practice (EBP) movement in healthcare emphasizes that clinical decision making should be based on the "best evidence" available, preferably the findings of randomized clinical trials. Within this context qualitative research findings are considered to have little value and the old debate in nursing has been re-ignited related to whether qualitative versus quantitative research findings provides the best empirical evidence for nursing practice. In response to this crisis qualitative scholars have been called upon by leaders in the field to clarify for outsiders what qualitative research is and to be more explicit in pointing out the utility of qualitative research findings. In addition, attention to "quality" in qualitative research has been identified as an area worthy of renewed focus. Within this paper two key problems related to addressing these issues are reviewed: disagreement not only among "outsiders" but also some nursing scholars related to the definition of "qualitative research", and a lack of consensus related how to best address "rigor" in this type of inquiry. Based on this review a set of standard requirements for qualitative research published in nursing journals is proposed that reflects a uniform definition of qualitative research and an enlarged yet clearly articulated conceptualization of quality. The approach suggested provides a framework for developing and evaluating qualitative research that would have both defensible scholarly merit and heuristic value. This will help solidify the argument in favor of incorporating qualitative research findings as part of the empirical "evidence" upon which evidence-based nursing is founded.
authors.affiliation: University of Connecticut School of Nursing, 231 Glenbrook Road, Unit 2026, Storrs, CT 06269-1246, USA. Antonia.nelson@uconn.edu <Antonia.nelson@uconn.edu>
authors.forename: Antonia M
authors.initials: AM
authors.lastname: Nelson
mesh_terms: D019317:Evidence-Based Medicine; D015399:Nursing Research; D036301:Qualitative Research; D011787:Quality of Health Care