Utility of follow-up recommendations for patients discharged with community-acquired pneumonia.
BACKGROUND
The joint Canadian Infectious Diseases Society and Canadian Thoracic Society guidelines for community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) recommend 48-72 hour telephone follow-up of patients discharged from the emergency department (ED). The guidelines provide no evidence supporting this practice, and neither the clinical utility nor the effectiveness of such recommendations has been assessed. Our objective was to assess the utility of a 48-72 hour telephone follow-up protocol for patients discharged from the ED with CAP.


METHODS
This was a retrospective chart audit covering a 2-year period (Jan. 3, 1999 to Jan. 3, 2001) after the introduction of a clinical practice guideline (CPG) that included routine 48-72 hour telephone follow-up of patients discharged from the ED with CAP. Eligible patients were identified in the ED database, rates of referral for telephone follow-up were recorded, and 30-day outcomes (death and readmission) for patients referred versus not referred were compared.


RESULTS
During the study period, 867 patients were identified as being eligible for the study. The mean age was 55.7 years (range 16-98 yr), and mean pneumonia severity index (PSI) was 68.9 (range 6-187). Despite the CPG, only 148 patients (17.1%) were referred for telephone follow-up. Age, demographics, comorbidity, clinical status and pneumonia severity were similar for referred and non-referred patients. Thirty-day death (2.5%) and readmission rates (3%) were strongly related to PSI score, but did not differ significantly in the 2 comparison groups.


CONCLUSIONS
In this setting, physicians were poorly compliant with a routine telephone follow-up protocol. The likelihood of referral for follow-up did not correlate with pneumonia severity, and follow-up referral did not appear to affect patient outcome. These findings do not support recommendations for routine early follow-up mechanisms beyond those already existing in the community.
Campbell
Sam G
SG
Department of Emergency Medicine, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. sgcampbe@dal.ca
Murray
Daphne D
DD
Urquhart
David G
DG
Maxwell
David M
DM
Ackroyd-Stolarz
Stacey Ann
SA
Varley-Doyle
Suzanne M
SM
Ells
Mabel D
MD
Hawass
Ammar
A