title: Selective activation around the left occipito-temporal sulcus for words relative to pictures: individual variability or false positives?
abstract: We used high-resolution fMRI to investigate claims that learning to read results in greater left occipito-temporal (OT) activation for written words relative to pictures of objects. In the first experiment, 9/16 subjects performing a one-back task showed activation in > or =1 left OT voxel for words relative to pictures (P < 0.05 uncorrected). In a second experiment, another 9/15 subjects performing a semantic decision task activated > or =1 left OT voxel for words relative to pictures. However, at this low statistical threshold false positives need to be excluded. The semantic decision paradigm was therefore repeated, within subject, in two different scanners (1.5 and 3 T). Both scanners consistently localised left OT activation for words relative to fixation and pictures relative to words, but there were no consistent effects for words relative to pictures. Finally, in a third experiment, we minimised the voxel size (1.5 x 1.5 x 1.5 mm(3)) and demonstrated a striking concordance between the voxels activated for words and pictures, irrespective of task (naming vs. one-back) or script (English vs. Hebrew). In summary, although we detected differential activation for words relative to pictures, these effects: (i) do not withstand statistical rigour; (ii) do not replicate within or between subjects; and (iii) are observed in voxels that also respond to pictures of objects. Our findings have implications for the role of left OT activation during reading. More generally, they show that studies using low statistical thresholds in single subject analyses should correct the statistical threshold for the number of comparisons made or replicate effects within subject.
authors: Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging, Institute of Neurology, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
authors: Nicholas D
authors: ND
authors: Wright
authors: Andrea
authors: A
authors: Mechelli
authors: Uta
authors: U
authors: Noppeney
authors: Dick J
authors: DJ
authors: Veltman
authors: Serge A R B
authors: SA
authors: Rombouts
authors: Janice
authors: J
authors: Glensman
authors: John-Dylan
authors: JD
authors: Haynes
authors: Cathy J
authors: CJ
authors: Price
mesh_terms: D000328:Adult; D001931:Brain Mapping / Q000379:methods; D005189:False Positive Reactions; D005260:Female; D006801:Humans; D007206:Individuality; D008297:Male; D008875:Middle Aged; D009778:Occipital Lobe / Q000502:physiology*; D010775:Photic Stimulation / Q000379:methods*; D011932:Reading; D013702:Temporal Lobe / Q000502:physiology*
references: Neuroimage. 2007 Mar;35(1):334-42
references: 17239621
references: Brain. 1999 Jan;122 ( Pt 1):61-73
references: 10050895
references: Neuropsychologia. 1998 Nov;36(11):1115-32
references: 9842758
references: Curr Opin Neurobiol. 2005 Apr;15(2):231-8
references: 15831408
references: Brain. 2000 Feb;123 ( Pt 2):291-307
references: 10648437
references: Neurology. 1983 Dec;33(12):1573-83
references: 6685830
references: Neuroimage. 1999 Aug;10(2):181-92
references: 10417250
references: Nature. 1996 Sep 19;383(6597):254-6
references: 8805700
references: Cogn Neuropsychol. 2005 May;22(3):262-75
references: 21038249
references: Hum Brain Mapp. 2002 Jul;16(3):168-75
references: 12112770
references: Nature. 2005 Nov 24;438(7067):496-9
references: 16244649
references: Neuroimage. 2005 Nov 15;28(3):738-44
references: 16109492
references: Neuron. 2002 Apr 25;34(3):479-90
references: 11988177
references: Neuroimage. 2007 Apr 15;35(3):1287-302
references: 17363278
references: J Cogn Neurosci. 2006 Jun;18(6):911-22
references: 16839299
references: Neuron. 2006 Apr 20;50(2):191-204
references: 16630832
references: Neuroimage. 2000 Oct;12(4):392-403
references: 10988033
references: Brain Res Cogn Brain Res. 2005 Aug;24(3):702-14
references: 15921900
references: Brain. 2002 May;125(Pt 5):1054-69
references: 11960895
references: Neuroimage. 2006 Jan 15;29(2):643-8
references: 16137894
references: Neuropsychologia. 1996 Mar;34(3):185-94
references: 8868276
references: Neuroimage. 2005 Jan 15;24(2):548-59
references: 15627597
references: Neuroimage. 2003 Jul;19(3):473-81
references: 12880781
references: Neuroimage. 2006 Aug 15;32(2):806-20
references: 16750396
references: Brain. 1987 Oct;110 ( Pt 5):1099-116
references: 3676694
references: Cereb Cortex. 2006 Mar;16(3):437-45
references: 15944370
references: Neuroimage. 2004 May;22(1):477-9
references: 15110041
references: J Cogn Neurosci. 2000 May;12(3):495-504
references: 10931774
references: J Exp Psychol Gen. 1989 Mar;118(1):13-42
references: 2522504
references: Neuroimage. 2004 May;22(1):466-76
references: 15110040
references: J Cogn Neurosci. 2005 Nov;17(11):1753-65
references: 16269111