title: Processing Elided Verb Phrases with Flawed Antecedents: the Recycling Hypothesis.
abstract: Traditional syntactic accounts of verb phrase ellipsis (e.g. "Jason laughed. Sam did [ ] too.") categorize as ungrammatical many sentences that language users find acceptable (they "undergenerate"); semantic accounts overgenerate. We propose that a processing theory, together with a syntactic account, does a better job of describing and explaining the data on verb phrase-ellipsis. Five acceptability judgment experiments supported a "VP recycling hypothesis," which claims that when a syntactically-matching antecedent is not available, the listener/reader creates one using the materials at hand. Experiments 1 and 2 used verb phrase ellipsis sentences with antecedents ranging from perfect (a verb phrase in matrix verb phrase position) to impossible (a verb phrase containing only a deverbal word). Experiments 3 and 4 contrasted antecedents in verbal versus nominal gerund subjects. Experiment 5 explored the possibility that speakers are particularly likely to go beyond the grammar and produce elided constituents without perfect matching antecedents when the antecedent needed is less marked than the antecedent actually produced. This experiment contrasted active (unmarked) and passive antecedents to show that readers seem to honor such a tendency.
authors: University of Ottawa.
authors: Ana
authors: A
authors: Arregui
authors: Charles
authors: C
authors: Clifton
authors: Lyn
authors: L
authors: Frazier
authors: Keir
authors: K
authors: Moulton
references: J Psycholinguist Res. 2002 Nov;31(6):633-59
references: 12599918
references: Cognition. 1996 Apr;59(1):23-59
references: 8857470
references: J Mem Lang. 2003 Jul 1;49(1):1-19
references: 23105168
references: Linguist Philos. 2006 Jun;29(3):315-346
references: 16896367
references: J Psycholinguist Res. 1995 Nov;24(6):517-32
references: 8531171
references: J Psycholinguist Res. 2000 Mar;29(2):125-39
references: 10709179
references: Lang Speech. 2001 Mar;44(Pt 1):1-26
references: 11430186