Alkali metal ion catalysis and inhibition in nucleophilic displacement reactions at phosphorus centers: ethyl and methyl paraoxon and ethyl and methyl parathion.
We report on the ethanolysis of the P=O and P=S compounds ethyl and methyl paraoxon (1a and 1b) and ethyl and methyl parathion (2a and 2b). Plots of spectrophotometrically measured rate constants, kobsd versus [MOEt], the alkali ethoxide concentration, show distinct upward and downward curvatures, pointing to the importance of ion-pairing phenomena and a differential reactivity of free ions and ion pairs. Three types of reactivity and selectivity patterns have been discerned: (1) For the P=O compounds 1a and 1b, LiOEt > NaOEt > KOEt > EtO-; (2) for the P=S compound 2a, KOEt > EtO- > NaOEt > LiOEt; (3) for P=S, 2b, 18C6-crown-complexed KOEt > KOEt = EtO(-) > NaOEt > LiOEt. These selectivity patterns are characteristic of both catalysis and inhibition by alkali-metal cations depending on the nature of the electrophilic center, P=O vs P=S, and the metal cation. Ground-state (GS) vs transition-state (TS) stabilization energies shed light on the catalytic and inhibitory tendencies. The unprecedented catalytic behavior of crowned-K(+) for the reaction of 2b is noteworthy. Modeling reveals an extreme steric interaction for the reaction of 2a with crowned-K(+), which is responsible for the absence of catalysis in this system. Overall, P=O exhibits greater reactivity than P=S, increasing from 50- to 60-fold with free EtO(-) and up to 2000-fold with LiOEt, reflecting an intrinsic P=O vs P=S reactivity difference (thio effect). The origin of reactivity and selectivity differences in these systems is discussed on the basis of competing electrostatic effects and solvational requirements as function of anionic electric field strength and cation size (Eisenman's theory).
Um
Ik-Hwan
IH
Division of Nano Sciences and Department of Chemistry, Ewha Womans University, Seoul 120-750, Korea. ihum@ewha.ac.kr
Shin
Young-Hee
YH
Lee
Seung-Eun
SE
Yang
Kiyull
K
Buncel
Erwin
E
D002384:Catalysis; D007477:Ions / Q000737:chemistry; D008672:Metals, Alkali / Q000737:chemistry*; D008745:Methylation; D008958:Models, Molecular; D015394:Molecular Structure; D010261:Paraoxon / Q000737:chemistry*; D010278:Parathion / Q000737:chemistry*; D010758:Phosphorus / Q000737:chemistry*; D055672:Static Electricity
D007477:Ions; D008672:Metals, Alkali; D010758:Phosphorus; D010278:Parathion; D010261:Paraoxon