title: Reverse genetics in ecological research.
abstract: By precisely manipulating the expression of individual genetic elements thought to be important for ecological performance, reverse genetics has the potential to revolutionize plant ecology. However, untested concerns about possible side-effects of the transformation technique, caused by Agrobacterium infection and tissue culture, on plant performance have stymied research by requiring onerous sample sizes. We compare 5 independently transformed Nicotiana attenuata lines harboring empty vector control (EVC) T-DNA lacking silencing information with isogenic wild types (WT), and measured a battery of ecologically relevant traits, known to be important in plant-herbivore interactions: phytohormones, secondary metabolites, growth and fitness parameters under stringent competitive conditions, and transcriptional regulation with microarrays. As a positive control, we included a line silenced in trypsin proteinase inhibitor gene (TPI) expression, a potent anti-herbivore defense known to exact fitness costs in its expression, in the analysis. The experiment was conducted twice, with 10 and 20 biological replicates per genotype. For all parameters, we detected no difference between any EVC and WT lines, but could readily detect a fitness benefit of silencing TPI production. A statistical power analyses revealed that the minimum sample sizes required for detecting significant fitness differences between EVC and WT was 2-3 orders of magnitude larger than the 10 replicates required to detect a fitness effect of TPI silencing. We conclude that possible side-effects of transformation are far too low to obfuscate the study of ecologically relevant phenotypes.
authors.affiliation: Department of Molecular Ecology, Max-Planck-Institute for Chemical Ecology, Jena, Germany.
authors.forename: Jens
authors.initials: J
authors.lastname: Schwachtje
authors.forename: Susan
authors.initials: S
authors.lastname: Kutschbach
authors.forename: Ian T
authors.initials: IT
authors.lastname: Baldwin
mesh_terms: D004463:Ecology; D018506:Gene Expression Regulation, Plant / Q000235:genetics; D020868:Gene Silencing; D018014:Gene Transfer Techniques / Q000592:standards; D008722:Methods; D030821:Plants, Genetically Modified; D012106:Research; D012231:Rhizobium / Q000235:genetics; D014026:Nicotiana / Q000235:genetics*; D014169:Transformation, Bacterial