Comparative risk analysis of dioxins in fish and fine particles from heavy-duty vehicles.
Dioxins and airborne fine particles are both environmental health problems that have been the subject of active public debate. Knowledge on fine particles has increased substantially during the last 10 years, and even the current, lowered levels in the Europe and in the United States appear to be a major public health problem. On the other hand, dioxins are ubiquitous persistent contaminants, some being carcinogens at high doses, and therefore of great concern. Our aim was to (a) quantitatively analyze the two pollutant health risks and (b) study the changes in risk in view of the current and forthcoming EU legislations on pollutants. We performed a comparative risk assessment for both pollutants in the Helsinki metropolitan area (Finland) and estimated the health effects with several scenarios. For primary fine particles: a comparison between the present emission situation for heavy-duty vehicles and the new fine particle emission standards set by the EU. For dioxins: an EU directive that regulates commercial fishing of Baltic salmon and herring that exceed the dioxin concentration limit set for fish meat, and a derogation (= exemption) from the directive for these two species. Both of these two decisions are very topical issues and this study estimates the expected changes in health effects due to these regulations. It was found that the estimated fine particle risk clearly outweighed the estimated dioxin risk. A substantial improvement to public health could be achieved by initiating reductions in emission standards; about 30 avoided premature deaths annually in the study area. In addition, the benefits of fish consumption due to omega-3 exposure were notably higher than the potential dioxin cancer risk. Both regulations were instigated as ways of promoting public health.
Leino
Olli
O
National Public Health Institute of Finland.
Tainio
Marko
M
Tuomisto
Jouni T
JT
D000818:Animals; D004032:Diet; D004147:Dioxins / Q000633:toxicity*; D005387:Finland; D005399:Fishes; D006801:Humans; D008460:Meat / Q000592:standards*; D018986:Motor Vehicles; D018570:Risk Assessment; D014505:Urban Population; D001335:Vehicle Emissions / Q000633:toxicity*
D004147:Dioxins; D001335:Vehicle Emissions