Evaluating online direct-to-consumer marketing of genetic tests: informed choices or buyers beware?
Commercialization of genetic technologies is expanding the horizons for the marketing and sales of genetic tests direct-to-consumers (DTCs). This study assesses the information provision and access requirements that are in place for genetic tests that are being advertised DTC over the Internet. Sets of key words specific to DTC genetic testing were entered into popular Internet search engines to generate a list of 24 companies engaging in DTC advertising. Company requirements for physician mediation, genetic counseling arrangements, and information provision were coded to develop categories for quantitative analysis within each variable. Results showed that companies offering risk assessment and diagnostic testing were most likely to require that testing be mediated by a clinician, and to recommend physician-arranged counseling. Companies offering enhancement testing were less likely to require physician mediation of services and more likely to provide long-distance genetic counseling. DTC advertisements often provided information on disease etiology; this was most common in the case of multifactorial diseases. The majority of companies cited outside sources to support the validity of claims about clinical utility of the tests being advertised; companies offering risk assessment tests most frequently cited all information sources. DTC advertising for genetic tests that lack independent professional oversight raises troubling questions about appropriate use and interpretation of these tests by consumers and carries implications for the standards of patient care. These implications are discussed in the context of a public healthcare system.
Geransar
Rose
R
Department of Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. rmgerans@ucalgary.ca
Einsiedel
Edna
E
D000329:Advertising; D003256:Community Participation; D005821:Genetic Techniques / Q000191:economics*; D006801:Humans; D007258:Informed Consent; D020407:Internet; D008389:Marketing of Health Services