Communicating genetic information in the family: enriching the debate through the notion of integrity.
Genetic information about one individual often has medical and reproductive implications for that individual's relatives. There is a debate about whether policy on transmitting genetic information within the family should change to reflect this shared aspect of genetic information. Even if laws on medical confidentiality remain unchanged, there still remains the question of professional practice and whether, to what extent and by what means professionals should encourage disclosure within a family. The debate so far has tended to focus on who has a right to genetic information, or has a right to decline genetic information, frequently drawing on the notion of individual autonomy. There are significant divergences within this debate, and difficulties with the use of autonomy in this context have been noted. This paper draws on theoretical considerations as well as on qualitative empirical data to show that shifting from talk of autonomy to talk of integrity will greatly enrich and illuminate the issues. It becomes possible to gain deeper insights into the ethical significance of the timing and the manner of such communication, the character of recipients of knowledge, and the nuanced nature of communication and different levels of understanding within a family.
Boddington
Paula
P
Ethox Centre, Oxford University, Badenoch Building, Old Road Campus, Headington, Oxford, OX3 7LF, UK. paula.boddington@ethox.ox.ac.uk
Gregory
Maggie
M
D003142:Communication; D030881:Disclosure; D005190:Family; D005195:Family Relations; D030661:Genetic Privacy; D006801:Humans; D012962:Sociology, Medical