Field test comparison of two dermal tolerance assessment methods of hand hygiene products.
This study aimed to compare the sensitivity and workload requirement of two dermal tolerance assessment methods of hand hygiene products, in order to select a suitable pilot testing method for field tests. An observer-rating method and a self-assessment method were compared in 12 voluntary hospital departments (autumn/winter of 2005-2006). Three test-periods of three weeks were separated by two-week intervals during which the routine products were reintroduced. The observer rating method scored dryness and irritation on four-point scales. In the self-assessment method, the user rated appearance, intactness, moisture content, and sensation on a visual analogue scale which was converted into a 10-point numerical scale. Eleven products (soaps) were tested (223/250 complete reports for observer rating, 131/251 for self-assessment). Two products were significantly less well tolerated than the routine product according to the observers, four products according to the self-assessments. There was no significant difference between the two methods when products were classified according to tolerance (Fisher's test: P=0.491). For the symptom common to both assessment methods (dryness), there is a good correlation between the two methods (Spearman's Rho: P=0.032). The workload was higher for observer rating method (288 h of observer time plus 122 h of prevention team and pharmacist time compared with 15 h of prevention team and pharmacist time for self-assessment). In conclusion, the self-assessment method was considered more suitable for pilot testing, although further time should be allocated for educational measures as the return rate of complete self-assessment forms was poor.
Girard
R
R
Hygiene and Epidemiology Unit, Centre Hospitalier Lyon Sud, Hospices Civils de Lyon, France. raphaelle.girard@chu-lyon.fr
Carré
E
E
Pires-Cronenberger
S
S
Bertin-Mandy
M
M
Favier-Bulit
M C
MC
Coyault
C
C
Coudrais
S
S
Billard
M
M
Regard
A
A
Kerhoas
A
A
Valdeyron
M L
ML
Cracco
B
B
Misslin
P
P
D004361:Drug Tolerance; D006235:Hand Disinfection; D006801:Humans; D012915:Soaps / Q000009:adverse effects*
D012915:Soaps