National HIV treatment guidelines in Tanzania and Ethiopia: are they legitimate rationing tools?
OBJECTIVE
To provide an ethical analysis of whether the Ethiopian and Tanzanian national HIV/AIDS treatment guidelines can be considered legitimate and fair rationing tools.


METHODS
Qualitative study and ethical analysis involving guideline documents and interviews with nine key members involved in the development of the guidelines. The analysis followed an editing organising style. The theoretical framework was a guideline-specific framework based on theories of just resource allocation in healthcare and conditions that ensure fair processes in guideline development. According to this framework, legitimate rationing requires reasons for patient selection to be explicit, public and relevant, and decisions must be open to question and revision.


RESULTS
The only explicit rationing criteria that both guidelines recommended were clinical antiretroviral treatment indications. Explicit non-clinical rationing criteria were expressed in a separate Ethiopian implementation guideline. Neither of the guideline development processes fully satisfies minimal requirements of procedural fairness. There is a lack of transparency. The reasons for decisions are rarely given and are not publicly available. This reduces the opportunity for public questioning, debate and revisions. The guidelines were based on expert opinion and consensus. Recommendations from the WHO were copied without much discussion, disagreement or adjustment.


CONCLUSIONS
The two national HIV treatment guidelines discussed are de facto mechanisms for rationing but were developed using methods that do not fully satisfy the requirements of fair processes.
Johansson
K A
KA
Division of Medical Ethics, Department of Public Health and Primary Health Care, Centre for International Health, University of Bergen, PB 7804, 5020 Bergen, Norway. Kjell.Johansson@isf.uib.no
Jerene
D
D
Norheim
O F
OF
D019380:Anti-HIV Agents / Q000627:therapeutic use*; D018791:CD4 Lymphocyte Count; D002648:Child; D026689:Ethical Analysis; D005002:Ethiopia; D005260:Female; D015658:HIV Infections / Q000188:drug therapy* / Q000276:immunology; D015276:Health Care Rationing / Q000941:ethics*; D006801:Humans; D007407:Interviews as Topic; D018579:Patient Selection / Q000941:ethics*; D017410:Practice Guidelines as Topic / Q000592:standards*; D011247:Pregnancy; D013636:Tanzania; D014944:World Health Organization
D019380:Anti-HIV Agents