Comment on "Quality of paraxial electromagnetic beams".
We comment on a recent paper by Seshadri [Appl. Opt.45, 5335 (2006)]APOPAI0003-693510.1364/AO.45.005335. In the cited work the author utilized the so-named Felsen method in order to derive the full wave expression of a scalar Bessel-Gauss field, propagating in free space, originated from an assigned input distribution on the source plane z = 0. As we show, the author's obtained results do not correctly reproduce the aforesaid input field distribution, as, on the contrary, they have to do.
El Gawhary
Omar
O
ing.elgawhary@hotmail.it
Severini
Sergio
S