Operant conditioning of enhanced pain sensitivity by heat-pain titration.
Operant conditioning mechanisms have been demonstrated to be important in the development of chronic pain. Most experimental studies have investigated the operant modulation of verbal pain reports with extrinsic reinforcement, such as verbal reinforcement. Whether this reflects actual changes in the subjective experience of the nociceptive stimulus remained unclear. This study replicates and extends our previous demonstration that enhanced pain sensitivity to prolonged heat-pain stimulation could be learned in healthy participants through intrinsic reinforcement (contingent changes in nociceptive input) independent of verbal pain reports. In addition, we examine whether different magnitudes of reinforcement differentially enhance pain sensitivity using an operant heat-pain titration paradigm. It is based on the previously developed non-verbal behavioral discrimination task for the assessment of sensitization, which uses discriminative down- or up-regulation of stimulus temperatures in response to changes in subjective intensity. In operant heat-pain titration, this discriminative behavior and not verbal pain report was contingently reinforced or punished by acute decreases or increases in heat-pain intensity. The magnitude of reinforcement was varied between three groups: low (N1=13), medium (N2=11) and high reinforcement (N3=12). Continuous reinforcement was applied to acquire and train the operant behavior, followed by partial reinforcement to analyze the underlying learning mechanisms. Results demonstrated that sensitization to prolonged heat-pain stimulation was enhanced by operant learning within 1h. The extent of sensitization was directly dependent on the received magnitude of reinforcement. Thus, operant learning mechanisms based on intrinsic reinforcement may provide an explanation for the gradual development of sustained hypersensitivity during pain that is becoming chronic.
Becker
Susanne
S
Otto-Selz-Institute for Applied Psychology, Mannheim Centre for Work and Health, Laboratory for Clinical Psychophysiology, University of Mannheim, Schloss EW 185, D-68131 Mannheim, Germany Department of Psychosomatic and Psychotherapy, Central Institute of Mental Health, University of Heidelberg, Germany.
Kleinböhl
Dieter
D
Klossika
Iris
I
Hölzl
Rupert
R
D000293:Adolescent; D000328:Adult; D003216:Conditioning, Operant; D005260:Female; D006358:Hot Temperature; D006801:Humans; D006930:Hyperalgesia / Q000503:physiopathology*; D008297:Male; D008875:Middle Aged; D017288:Pain Threshold; D055815:Young Adult
Baker SL, Kirsch I. Cognitive mediators of pain perception and tolerance. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1991;61:504-510.
Benjamini Y, Hochberg Y. Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. J R Stat Soc. 1995;57:289-300.
Bliss TV, Collingridge GL. A synaptic model of memory: long-term potentiation in the hippocampus. Nature. 1993;361:31-39.
Bloom CM, Venard J, Harden M, Seetharaman S. Non-contingent positive and negative reinforcement schedules of superstitious behaviors. Behav Processes. 2007;75:8-13.
Blough DSA. A method for obtaining psychophysical thresholds from the pigeon. J Exp Anal Behav. 1958;1:31-43.
Bousema EJ, Verbunt JA, Seelen HA, Vlaeyen JW, Knottnerus JA. Disuse and physical deconditioning in the first year after the onset of back pain. Pain. 2007;130:279-286.
Brennum J, Dahl JB, Moiniche S, Arendt-Nielsen L. Quantitative sensory examination of epidural anaesthesia and analgesia in man: effects of pre- and post-traumatic morphine on hyperalgesia. Pain. 1994;59:261-271.
Bushnell MC, Duncan GH, Dubner R, Jones RL, Maixner W. Attentional influences on noxious and innocuous cutaneous heat detection in humans and monkeys. J Neurosci. 1985;5:1103-1110.
Bushnell MC, Taylor MB, Duncan GH, Dubner R. Discrimination of innocuous and noxious thermal stimuli applied to the face in human and monkey. Somatosens Res. 1983;1:119-129.
Cowey A. The 30th Sir Frederick Bartlett lecture Fact, artefact, and myth about blindsight. Q J Exp Psychol A. 2004;57:577-609.
Dahl JB, Brennum J, Arendt-Nielsen L, Jensen TS, Kehlet H. The effect of pre- versus post-injury infiltration with lidocaine on thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia after heat injury to the skin. Pain. 1993;53:43-51.
Dykstra LA, McMillan DE. Electric shock titration: effects of morphine, metadone, pentazocine, naloriphine, naloxone, diazepam and amphetamine. J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 1977;202:660-669.
Easterling KW, Holtzman SG. Parametric changes in response equilibrium during an intra-cranial self stimulation (ICSS) task: can reward value be assessed independently of absolute threshold. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 1997;21:55-65.
Eide PK. Wind-up and the NMDA receptor complex from a clinical perspective. Eur J Pain. 2000;4:5-15.
Erdelyi MH. Subliminal perception and its cognates: theory, indeterminacy, and time. Conscious Cogn. 2004;13:73-91.
Fishbain DA, Cole B, Cutler RB, Lewis J, Rosomoff HL, Rosomoff RS. A structured evidence-based review on the meaning of nonorganic physical signs: Waddell signs. Pain Med. 2003;4:141-181.
Flor H. Painful memories Can we train chronic pain patients to ‘forget’ their pain. EMBO Rep. 2002;3:288-291.
Flor H, Diers M. Limitations of pharmacotherapy: behavioral approaches to chronic pain. Handb Exp Pharmacol. 2007;177:415-427.
Flor H, Knost B, Birbaumer N. Processing of pain- and body-related verbal material in chronic pain patients: central and peripheral correlates. Pain. 1997;73:413-421.
Flor H, Knost B, Birbaumer N. The role of operant conditioning in chronic pain: an experimental investigation. Pain. 2002;95:111-118.
Fordyce WE. A behavioral perspective on chronic pain. Br J Clin Psychol. 1982;21:313-320.
Galfe G, Lautenbacher S, Hölzl R, Strian F. Diagnosis of small-fiber neuropathy: computer-assisted methods of combined pain and thermal sensitivity determination. Hospimedica. 1990;8:38-48.
Hanks GW, Nugent M, Higgs CM, Busch MA. Oral transmucosal fentanyl citrate in the management of breakthrough pain in cancer: an open, multicentre, dose-titration and long-term use study. Palliat Med. 2004;18:698-704.
Hölzl R, Kleinböhl D, Huse E. Implicit operant learning of pain sensitization. Pain. 2005;115:12-20.
Jolliffe CD, Nicholas MK. Verbally reinforcing pain reports: an experimental test of the operant model of chronic pain. Pain. 2004;107:167-175.
Kakkar RK, Berry RB. Positive airway pressure treatment for obstructive sleep apnea. Chest. 2007;132:1057-1072.
Keefe FJ, Dunsmore J, Burnett R. Behavioral and cognitive-behavioral approaches to chronic pain: recent advances and future directions. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1992;60:528-536.
Kleinböhl D, Hölzl R, Möltner A, Rommel C, Weber C, Osswald PM. Psychophysical measures of sensitization to tonic heat discriminate chronic pain patients. Pain. 1999;81:35-43.
Lea SE. Titration of schedule parameters by pigeons. J Exp Anal Behav. 1976;25:43-54.
Leeuw M, Goossens ME, Linton SJ, Crombez G, Boersma K, Vlaeyen JW. The fear-avoidance model of musculoskeletal pain: current state of scientific evidence. J Behav Med. 2007;30:77-94.
Lethem J, Slade PD, Troup JD, Bentley G. Outline of a fear-avoidance model of exaggerated pain perception-I. Behav Res Ther. 1983;21:401-408.
Linton SJ, Götestam KG. Controlling pain reports through operant conditioning: a laboratory demonstration. Percept Mot Skills. 1985;60:427-437.
Littell RC, Henry PR, Ammerman CB. Statistical analysis of repeated measures data using SAS procedures. J Anim Sci. 1998;76:1216-1231.
Lousberg R, Groenman NH, Schmidt AJ, Gielen AA. Operant conditioning of the pain experience. Percept Mot Skills. 1996;83:883-900.
Lousberg R, Vuurman E, Lamers T, Van Breukelen G, Jongen E, Rijnen H, et al. Pain report and pain-related evoked potentials operantly conditioned. Clin J Pain. 2005;21:262-271.
Maixner W, Dubner R, Bushnell MC, Kenshalo DR, Oliveras J. Wide-dynamic-range dorsal horn neurons participate in the encoding process by which monkeys perceive the intensity of noxious heat stimuli. Brain Res. 1986;374:385-388.
Maixner W, Dubner R, Kenshalo DR, Bushnell MC, Oliveras J. Responses of monkey medullary dorsal horn neurons during the detection of noxious heat stimuli. J Neurophysiol. 1989;62:437-449.
Matthews BA, Shimoff E, Catania AC, Sagvolden T. Uninstructed human responding: sensitivity to ratio and interval contingencies. J Exp Anal Behav. 1977;27:453-467.
Miltner W, Larbig W, Braun C. Biofeedback of somatosensory event-related potentials: can individual pain sensations be modified by biofeedback-induced self-control of event-related potentials. Pain. 1988;35:205-213.
Molton IR, Graham C, Stoelb BL, Jensen MP. Current psychological approaches to the management of chronic pain. Curr Opin Anaesthesiol. 2007;20:485-489.
Pedersen JL, Andersen OK, Arendt-Nielsen L, Kehlet H. Hyperalgesia and temporal summation of pain after heat injury in man. Pain. 1998;74:189-197.
Ploghaus A, Narain C, Beckmann CF, Clare S, Bantick S, Wise R, et al. Exacerbation of pain by anxiety is associated with activity in a hippocampal network. J Neurosci. 2001;21:9896-9903.
Sandkühler J. Learning and memory in pain pathways. Pain. 2000;88:113-118.
Scott WE, Farh J, Podsakoff PM. The effects of “intrinsic” and “extrinsic” reinforcement contingencies on task behavior. Organ Behav Hum Decis Process. 1988;41:405-425.
Skinner BF. Superstition in the pigeon. J Exp Psychol. 1948;38:168-172.
Staud R. Biology and therapy of fibromyalgia: pain in fibromyalgia syndrome. Arthritis Res Ther. 2006;8:208.
Vlaeyen JW, Linton SJ. Fear-avoidance and its consequences in chronic musculoskeletal pain: a state of the art. Pain. 2000;85:317-332.
Waddell G, Newton M, Henderson I, Somerville D, Main CJ. A fear-avoidance beliefs questionnaire (FABQ) and the role of fear-avoidance beliefs in chronic low back pain and disability. Pain. 1993;52:157-168.
Weiskrantz L. Roots of blindsight. Prog Brain Res. 2004;144:229-241.
Weiss B, Laties V. Titration behavior on various fractional escape programs. J Exp Anal Behav. 1959;2:227-248.
Weiss B, Laties V. Characteristics of aversive thresholds measured by a titration schedule. J Exp Anal Behav. 1963;6:563-572.
Weitzman ED, Ross GS, Hodos W, Galambos R. Behavioral method for study of pain in monkey. Science. 1961;133:37-38.