Factors associated with experts' opinions regarding criminal responsibility in The Netherlands.
In many jurisdictions, offenders need to have freely chosen to commit their crimes in order to be punishable. A mental defect or disorder may be a reason for diminished or total absence of criminal responsibility and may remove culpability. This study aims to provide an empirically based understanding of the factors on which experts base their judgements concerning criminal responsibility. Clinical, demographic and crime related variables, as well as MMPI-2 profiles, were collected from final reports concerning defendants of serious crime submitted to the observation clinic of the Dutch Ministry of Justice for a criminal responsibility assessment. Criminal responsibility was expressed along a five-point scale corresponding to the Dutch legal practice. Results showed that several variables contributed independently to experts' opinions regarding criminal responsibility: diagnosis (Axis I and II), cultural background, type of weapon used in committing the crime, and whether the defendant committed the crime alone or with others. In contract to jurisdictions involving a sane/insane dichotomy, the Dutch five-point scale of criminal responsibility revealed that Axis II personality disorders turned out to be mostly associated with a diminished responsibility. MMPI-2 scores also turned out to have a small contribution to experts' opinions on criminal responsibility, independently of mere diagnostic variables. These results suggest that experts base their judgements not only on the presence or absence of mental disorders, but also on cultural and crime related characteristics, as well as dimensional information about the defendant's personality and symptomatology.
Barendregt
Marko
M
yNetherlands Institute of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology, Location Pieter Baan Centre, Utrecht, The Netherlands. m.barendregt2@dji.minjus.nl
Muller
Eline
E
Nijman
Henk
H
de Beurs
Edwin
E
D003415:Crime / Q000523:psychology; D003416:Criminal Law; D005104:Expert Testimony; D006801:Humans; D016365:Liability, Legal; D008297:Male; D016743:Mental Competency / Q000523:psychology; D009426:Netherlands; D010555:Personality Inventory; D012044:Regression Analysis; D011795:Surveys and Questionnaires