Management of neonatal testicular torsion: Which way to turn?
OBJECTIVE
Perinatal testicular torsion (PTT) is a rare event with controversies surrounding its etiology, prebsentation, surgical management and sequelae. Our survey assessed the preferences of pediatric urologists with regard to its management.


METHODS
Four cases of unilateral PTT and a questionnaire containing 11 questions about management of common clinical scenarios were mailed to 26 pediatric urologists. The answers were received anonymously and they were analyzed blindly.


RESULTS
The response rate was 80% (21/26), with 90% (19/21) of respondents holding academic appointments. In the 2 first cases of PTT with a typical unilateral nonviable testis, 76% (16/21) and 67% (14/21), respectively, opted for surgery. A case of acute postnatal torsion resulted in 100% agreement to urgent scrotal exploration. In the case of an atrophic testis, none of the respondents opted for immediate surgery; yet, 38% (8/21) said they would proceed with a delayed orchiopexy of the contralateral testicle. In the question section, 10% (2/21) responded that they preferred to explore PTT immediately; whereas, 57% (12/21) would delay surgical exploration for a few days until the neonate was better stabilized. One-third of participants (7/21) would not perform a surgical exploration but would just follow the child clinically. A scrotal incision for contralateral orchiopexy was preferred by 52% (11/21), while 48% (10/21) prefer a scrotal approach but would switch to an inguinal incision if a hydrocele were present. Operative intervention was favoured by 80% (8/10) and 46% (5/11) of those with less than and greater than 10 years of practice, respectively.


CONCLUSIONS
This survey revealed that 67% (14/21) of respondents preferred immediate exploration of a torted testis and contralateral orchiopexy, compared with the nonoperative approach. Scrotal incision for the exploration was preferred by most respondents. There was a trend to choose less aggressive treatment as the years of practice increase. Studies of more robust design, such as randomized controlled trials, are necessary to determine the natural history and outcomes of this uncommon type of testicular torsion.
Guerra
Luis A
LA
Division of Paediatric Urology, University of Ottawa, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario, Ottawa Ont.
Wiesenthal
Joshua
J
Pike
John
J
Leonard
Michael P
MP
J Urol. 1995 Mar;153(3 Pt 1):782-4
7861538
Am J Dis Child. 1965 Dec;110(6):676-7
5844115
Can J Anaesth. 1993 Nov;40(11):1065-8
8269568
J Urol. 2007 Jun;177(6):2296-9
17509343
J Urol. 2005 Oct;174(4 Pt 2):1579-82; discussion 1582-3
16148656
J Urol. 1990 Feb;143(2):231-3
2405183
Urology. 1980 Dec;16(6):604-5
7445309
JAMA. 1966 Dec 5;198(10):1123-4
5953395
J Pediatr. 1967 Aug;71(2):249-50
6029473
J Urol. 1976 Oct;116(4):508-9
1053346
J Urol. 1976 Jul;116(1):128-9
933276
J Pediatr. 1948 Sep;33(3):323-7
18880080
J Med Genet. 1975 Mar;12(1):112-3
1121017
J Urol. 1992 Mar;147(3):670-2
1538453
J Clin Anesth. 1992 Nov-Dec;4(6):455-61
1457112
J Urol. 1980 Feb;123(2):293
7354546