Revisiting the classics: considering nonconsumptive effects in textbook examples of predator-prey interactions.
Predator effects on prey dynamics are conventionally studied by measuring changes in prey abundance attributed to consumption by predators. We revisit four classic examples of predator-prey systems often cited in textbooks and incorporate subsequent studies of nonconsumptive effects of predators (NCE), defined as changes in prey traits (e.g., behavior, growth, development) measured on an ecological time scale. Our review revealed that NCE were integral to explaining lynx-hare population dynamics in boreal forests, cascading effects of top predators in Wisconsin lakes, and cascading effects of killer whales and sea otters on kelp forests in nearshore marine habitats. The relative roles of consumption and NCE of wolves on moose and consequent indirect effects on plant communities of Isle Royale depended on climate oscillations. Nonconsumptive effects have not been explicitly tested to explain the link between planktonic alewives and the size structure of the zooplankton, nor have they been invoked to attribute keystone predator status in intertidal communities or elsewhere. We argue that both consumption and intimidation contribute to the total effects of keystone predators, and that characteristics of keystone consumers may differ from those of predators having predominantly NCE. Nonconsumptive effects are often considered as an afterthought to explain observations inconsistent with consumption-based theory. Consequently, NCE with the same sign as consumptive effects may be overlooked, even though they can affect the magnitude, rate, or scale of a prey response to predation and can have important management or conservation implications. Nonconsumptive effects may underlie other classic paradigms in ecology, such as delayed density dependence and predator-mediated prey coexistence. Revisiting classic studies enriches our understanding of predator-prey dynamics and provides compelling rationale for ramping up efforts to consider how NCE affect traditional predator-prey models based on consumption, and to compare the relative magnitude of consumptive and NCE of predators.
Peckarsky
Barbara L
BL
Department of Zoology, 453 Birge Hall, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, USA. peckarsky@wisc.edu
Abrams
Peter A
PA
Bolnick
Daniel I
DI
Dill
Lawrence M
LM
Grabowski
Jonathan H
JH
Luttbeg
Barney
B
Orrock
John L
JL
Peacor
Scott D
SD
Preisser
Evan L
EL
Schmitz
Oswald J
OJ
Trussell
Geoffrey C
GC
D000818:Animals; D017753:Ecosystem; D008954:Models, Biological; D011157:Population Dynamics; D011235:Predatory Behavior