Reliability of surgical skills scores in otolaryngology residents: analysis using generalizability theory.
Assessments of temporal bone dissection performance among otolaryngology residents have not been adequately developed. At the Ohio State College of Medicine, an instrument (Welling Scale, Version 1 [WS1]) is used to evaluate residents' end-product performance after drilling a temporal bone. In this study, the authors evaluate the components that contribute to measurement error using this scale. Generalizability theory was used to reveal components of measurement error that allow for better understanding of test results. A major component of measurement error came from inconsistency in performance across the two cadaveric test bones each resident was assigned. In contrast, ratings of performance using the WS1 were highly consistent across raters and rating sessions within raters. The largest source of measurement error was caused by residents' inconsistent performance across bones. Rater disagreement introduced only small error into scores. The WS1 provides small measurement error, with two raters and two bones for each participant.
Fernandez
Soledad A
SA
Ohio State University, Columbus, USA. Soledad.Fernandez@osumc.edu
Wiet
Gregory J
GJ
Butler
Nancy N
NN
Welling
Bradley
B
Jarjoura
David
D
D002983:Clinical Competence; D004521:Educational Measurement / Q000379:methods*; D006801:Humans; D007396:Internship and Residency; D010036:Otolaryngology / Q000193:education*; D013517:Otorhinolaryngologic Surgical Procedures / Q000193:education* / Q000592:standards; D015203:Reproducibility of Results