Will the introduction of an emotional context affect fingerprint analysis and decision-making?
Fingerprint identification relies on an expert's ability to accurately recognise differences and similarities in friction ridge detail. The process is open to the questioning of an expert's ability to accurately analyse and interpret friction ridges. It has been suggested that the interpretation and analysis of fingermarks becomes more subjective as clarity decreases and as a consequence the expert is more vulnerable to external stimuli. An experiment involving 70 fingerprint experts was conducted to establish whether the introduction of an emotional context would alter the experts' judgement of an ambiguous or poor quality mark. The emotional context did have a perceived effect on the experts' analysis, as more stated they were affected by the information they were given. However, it did not have any actual effect on their final opinions as no difference was observed between the high- and low-emotional contexts.
Directorate of Forensic Services, Metropolitan Police Service, New Scotland Yard, 10 Broadway, London SW1H OBG, UK. lisa.hall@met.police.uk
Lisa J
LJ
Hall
Emma
E
Player
D003415:Crime; D003657:Decision Making; D003878:Dermatoglyphics; D004644:Emotions; D006801:Humans; D007600:Judgment