Comment on "Renormalization-group theory for the phase-field crystal equation".
Athreya, Goldenfeld, and Dantzig [Phys. Rev. E 74, 011601 (2006)] claim that the current implementation of the renormalization-group method neglects the proper ordering of renormalization and differentiation. Their analysis is, however, based on the wrong multiple-scales method results.
Shiwa
Y
Y