The timing and influence of MRI on the management of patients with cervical facet dislocations remains highly variable: a survey of members of the Spine Trauma Study Group.
BACKGROUND
Traumatic cervical facet dislocations are potentially devastating injuries. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an excellent means of assessing ligamentous disruption, disk herniation, and compression of the neural elements. However, despite an improved understanding of these facet dislocations with imaging, treatment remains controversial.


OBJECTIVE
To survey the timing and influence of MRI on the management of patients with traumatic cervical facet dislocations.


METHODS
Questionnaire study.


METHODS
Clinical vignettes, plain radiographs, and computed tomography scans of 10 cases of cervical facet dislocation were presented to 25 fellowship trained spine surgeons. Participants were analyzed as to their next step in diagnosis or treatment: closed reduction, obtaining an MRI, or proceeding directly with open treatment. A revised vignette was then presented; however, on this occasion, an MRI was included with the imaging and had been obtained before a reduction attempt. Participants were then surveyed on their choice of closed or open reduction. Each of the vignettes consisted of 3 different clinical scenarios based on neurologic examination: intact, incomplete, or complete spinal cord injury.


RESULTS
The interrater reliability of treatment decisions was very poor, and the reliability after MRI was available and was significantly worse when the patient was considered to have a complete spinal cord injury. After reviewing the MRI, orthopedic surgeons were significantly more likely to choose a closed versus open reduction. Neurosurgeons were significantly more likely than orthopedic surgeons to order an MRI before open or closed treatment.


CONCLUSIONS
The timing and utilization of MRI for patients with traumatic cervical facet dislocations remains variable. Further outcome analysis in the form of evidence-based algorithms is necessary to optimize patient management and outcomes.
Grauer
Jonathan N
JN
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06510, USA. jonathan.grauer@yale.edu
Vaccaro
Alexander R
AR
Lee
Joon Y
JY
Nassr
Ahmad
A
Dvorak
Marcel F
MF
Harrop
James S
JS
Dailey
Andrew T
AT
Shaffrey
Christopher I
CI
Arnold
Paul M
PM
Brodke
Darrel S
DS
Rampersaud
Raja
R