"Do you see yonder cloud?"--On priming concepts, a new test, and a familiar outcome. Reply to Lucas et al.: "Familiarity or conceptual priming? Good question! Comment on Stenberg, Hellman, Johansson, and Rosén (2009)".
Lucas, Voss, and Paller sympathize with our intentions but disagree with our findings. They argue that a relation between frequency and conceptual priming may have been obscured by methodological details in our second experiment, therefore failing to complete a bridge between conceptual priming and FN400 with name frequency as the mediator. However, renewed inspections of our experiment and a new additional experiment, designed to meet the objections, fail to find any role for name frequency in conceptual priming and therefore re-establish the dissociation of priming and the FN400. On closer inspection, our differing views seem to derive from different interpretations of the term "concept."
Georg
G
Stenberg
Mikael
M
Johansson
Johan
J
Hellman
Ingmar
I
Rosén
D001479:Basal Ganglia / Q000502:physiology*; D002608:Charities; D006801:Humans; D009042:Motivation / Q000502:physiology*; D012919:Social Behavior