title: Different likelihood ratio approaches to evaluate the strength of evidence of MDMA tablet comparisons.
abstract: Two likelihood ratio (LR) approaches are presented to evaluate the strength of evidence of MDMA tablet comparisons. The first one is based on a more 'traditional' comparison of MDMA tablets by using distance measures (e.g., Pearson correlation distance or a Euclidean distance). In this approach, LRs are calculated using the distribution of distances between tablets of the same-batch and that of different-batches. The second approach is based on methods used in some other fields of forensic comparison. Here LRs are calculated based on the distribution of values of MDMA tablet characteristics within a specific batch and from all batches. The data used in this paper must be seen as examples to illustrate both methods. In future research the methods can be applied to other and more complex data. In this paper, the methods and their results are discussed, considering their performance in evidence evaluation and several practical aspects. With respect to evidence in favor of the correct hypothesis, the second method proved to be better than the first one. It is shown that the LRs in same-batch comparisons are generally higher compared to the first method and the LRs in different-batch comparisons are generally lower. On the other hand, for operational purposes (where quick information is needed), the first method may be preferred, because it is less time consuming. With this method a model has to be estimated only once in a while, which means that only a few measurements have to be done, while with the second method more measurements are needed because each time a new model has to be estimated.
authors.affiliation: Netherlands Forensic Institute, 2490 AA The Hague, The Netherlands. a.bolck@nfi.minjus.nl
authors.forename: Annabel
authors.initials: A
authors.lastname: Bolck
authors.forename: Céline
authors.initials: C
authors.lastname: Weyermann
authors.forename: Laurence
authors.initials: L
authors.lastname: Dujourdy
authors.forename: Pierre
authors.initials: P
authors.lastname: Esseiva
authors.forename: Jorrit
authors.initials: J
authors.lastname: van den Berg