An upper limit on the stochastic gravitational-wave background of cosmological origin.
A stochastic background of gravitational waves is expected to arise from a superposition of a large number of unresolved gravitational-wave sources of astrophysical and cosmological origin. It should carry unique signatures from the earliest epochs in the evolution of the Universe, inaccessible to standard astrophysical observations. Direct measurements of the amplitude of this background are therefore of fundamental importance for understanding the evolution of the Universe when it was younger than one minute. Here we report limits on the amplitude of the stochastic gravitational-wave background using the data from a two-year science run of the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO). Our result constrains the energy density of the stochastic gravitational-wave background normalized by the critical energy density of the Universe, in the frequency band around 100 Hz, to be <6.9 x 10(-6) at 95% confidence. The data rule out models of early Universe evolution with relatively large equation-of-state parameter, as well as cosmic (super)string models with relatively small string tension that are favoured in some string theory models. This search for the stochastic background improves on the indirect limits from Big Bang nucleosynthesis and cosmic microwave background at 100 Hz.
Lists of participants and their affiliations appear at the end of the paper.
Abbott
B P
BP
Abbott
R
R
Acernese
F
F
Adhikari
R
R
Ajith
P
P
Allen
B
B
Allen
G
G
Alshourbagy
M
M
Amin
R S
RS
Anderson
S B
SB
Anderson
W G
WG
Antonucci
F
F
Aoudia
S
S
Arain
M A
MA
Araya
M
M
Armandula
H
H
Armor
P
P
Arun
K G
KG
Aso
Y
Y
Aston
S
S
Astone
P
P
Aufmuth
P
P
Aulbert
C
C
Babak
S
S
Baker
P
P
Ballardin
G
G
Ballmer
S
S
Barker
C
C
Barker
D
D
Barone
F
F
Barr
B
B
Barriga
P
P
Barsotti
L
L
Barsuglia
M
M
Barton
M A
MA
Bartos
I
I
Bassiri
R
R
Bastarrika
M
M
Bauer
Th S
TS
Behnke
B
B
Beker
M
M
Benacquista
M
M
Betzwieser
J
J
Beyersdorf
P T
PT
Bigotta
S
S
Bilenko
I A
IA
Billingsley
G
G
Birindelli
S
S
Biswas
R
R
Bizouard
M A
MA
Black
E
E
Blackburn
J K
JK
Blackburn
L
L
Blair
D
D
Bland
B
B
Boccara
C
C
Bodiya
T P
TP
Bogue
L
L
Bondu
F
F
Bonelli
L
L
Bork
R
R
Boschi
V
V
Bose
S
S
Bosi
L
L
Braccini
S
S
Bradaschia
C
C
Brady
P R
PR
Braginsky
V B
VB
Brand
J F J van den
JF
Brau
J E
JE
Bridges
D O
DO
Brillet
A
A
Brinkmann
M
M
Brisson
V
V
Van Den Broeck
C
C
Brooks
A F
AF
Brown
D A
DA
Brummit
A
A
Brunet
G
G
Bullington
A
A
Bulten
H J
HJ
Buonanno
A
A
Burmeister
O
O
Buskulic
D
D
Byer
R L
RL
Cadonati
L
L
Cagnoli
G
G
Calloni
E
E
Camp
J B
JB
Campagna
E
E
Cannizzo
J
J
Cannon
K C
KC
Canuel
B
B
Cao
J
J
Carbognani
F
F
Cardenas
L
L
Caride
S
S
Castaldi
G
G
Caudill
S
S
Cavaglià
M
M
Cavalier
F
F
Cavalieri
R
R
Cella
G
G
Cepeda
C
C
Cesarini
E
E
Chalermsongsak
T
T
Chalkley
E
E
Charlton
P
P
Chassande-Mottin
E
E
Chatterji
S
S
Chelkowski
S
S
Chen
Y
Y
Christensen
N
N
Chung
C T Y
CT
Clark
D
D
Clark
J
J
Clayton
J H
JH
Cleva
F
F
Coccia
E
E
Cokelaer
T
T
Colacino
C N
CN
Colas
J
J
Colla
A
A
Colombini
M
M
Conte
R
R
Cook
D
D
Corbitt
T R C
TR
Corda
C
C
Cornish
N
N
Corsi
A
A
Coulon
J-P
JP
Coward
D
D
Coyne
D C
DC
Creighton
J D E
JD
Creighton
T D
TD
Cruise
A M
AM
Culter
R M
RM
Cumming
A
A
Cunningham
L
L
Cuoco
E
E
Danilishin
S L
SL
D'Antonio
S
S
Danzmann
K
K
Dari
A
A
Dattilo
V
V
Daudert
B
B
Davier
M
M
Davies
G
G
Daw
E J
EJ
Day
R
R
De Rosa
R
R
Debra
D
D
Degallaix
J
J
Del Prete
M
M
Dergachev
V
V
Desai
S
S
Desalvo
R
R
Dhurandhar
S
S
Di Fiore
L
L
Di Lieto
A
A
Di Paolo Emilio
M
M
Di Virgilio
A
A
Díaz
M
M
Dietz
A
A
Donovan
F
F
Dooley
K L
KL
Doomes
E E
EE
Drago
M
M
Drever
R W P
RW
Dueck
J
J
Duke
I
I
Dumas
J-C
JC
Dwyer
J G
JG
Echols
C
C
Edgar
M
M
Effler
A
A
Ehrens
P
P
Ely
G
G
Espinoza
E
E
Etzel
T
T
Evans
M
M
Evans
T
T
Fafone
V
V
Fairhurst
S
S
Faltas
Y
Y
Fan
Y
Y
Fazi
D
D
Fehrmann
H
H
Ferrante
I
I
Fidecaro
F
F
Finn
L S
LS
Fiori
I
I
Flaminio
R
R
Flasch
K
K
Foley
S
S
Forrest
C
C
Fotopoulos
N
N
Fournier
J-D
JD
Franc
J
J
Franzen
A
A
Frasca
S
S
Frasconi
F
F
Frede
M
M
Frei
M
M
Frei
Z
Z
Freise
A
A
Frey
R
R
Fricke
T
T
Fritschel
P
P
Frolov
V V
VV
Fyffe
M
M
Galdi
V
V
Gammaitoni
L
L
Garofoli
J A
JA
Garufi
F
F
Genin
E
E
Gennai
A
A
Gholami
I
I
Giaime
J A
JA
Giampanis
S
S
Giardina
K D
KD
Giazotto
A
A
Goda
K
K
Goetz
E
E
Goggin
L M
LM
González
G
G
Gorodetsky
M L
ML
Gobler
S
S
Gouaty
R
R
Granata
M
M
Granata
V
V
Grant
A
A
Gras
S
S
Gray
C
C
Gray
M
M
Greenhalgh
R J S
RJ
Gretarsson
A M
AM
Greverie
C
C
Grimaldi
F
F
Grosso
R
R
Grote
H
H
Grunewald
S
S
Guenther
M
M
Guidi
G
G
Gustafson
E K
EK
Gustafson
R
R
Hage
B
B
Hallam
J M
JM
Hammer
D
D
Hammond
G D
GD
Hanna
C
C
Hanson
J
J
Harms
J
J
Harry
G M
GM
Harry
I W
IW
Harstad
E D
ED
Haughian
K
K
Hayama
K
K
Heefner
J
J
Heitmann
H
H
Hello
P
P
Heng
I S
IS
Heptonstall
A
A
Hewitson
M
M
Hild
S
S
Hirose
E
E
Hoak
D
D
Hodge
K A
KA
Holt
K
K
Hosken
D J
DJ
Hough
J
J
Hoyland
D
D
Huet
D
D
Hughey
B
B
Huttner
S H
SH
Ingram
D R
DR
Isogai
T
T
Ito
M
M
Ivanov
A
A
Johnson
B
B
Johnson
W W
WW
Jones
D I
DI
Jones
G
G
Jones
R
R
Sancho de la Jordana
L
L
Ju
L
L
Kalmus
P
P
Kalogera
V
V
Kandhasamy
S
S
Kanner
J
J
Kasprzyk
D
D
Katsavounidis
E
E
Kawabe
K
K
Kawamura
S
S
Kawazoe
F
F
Kells
W
W
Keppel
D G
DG
Khalaidovski
A
A
Khalili
F Y
FY
Khan
R
R
Khazanov
E
E
King
P
P
Kissel
J S
JS
Klimenko
S
S
Kokeyama
K
K
Kondrashov
V
V
Kopparapu
R
R
Koranda
S
S
Kozak
D
D
Krishnan
B
B
Kumar
R
R
Kwee
P
P
La Penna
P
P
Lam
P K
PK
Landry
M
M
Lantz
B
B
Laval
M
M
Lazzarini
A
A
Lei
H
H
Lei
M
M
Leindecker
N
N
Leonor
I
I
Leroy
N
N
Letendre
N
N
Li
C
C
Lin
H
H
Lindquist
P E
PE
Littenberg
T B
TB
Lockerbie
N A
NA
Lodhia
D
D
Longo
M
M
Lorenzini
M
M
Loriette
V
V
Lormand
M
M
Losurdo
G
G
Lu
P
P
Lubinski
M
M
Lucianetti
A
A
Lück
H
H
Machenschalk
B
B
Macinnis
M
M
Mackowski
J-M
JM
Mageswaran
M
M
Mailand
K
K
Majorana
E
E
Man
N
N
Mandel
I
I
Mandic
V
V
Mantovani
M
M
Marchesoni
F
F
Marion
F
F
Márka
S
S
Márka
Z
Z
Markosyan
A
A
Markowitz
J
J
Maros
E
E
Marque
J
J
Martelli
F
F
Martin
I W
IW
Martin
R M
RM
Marx
J N
JN
Mason
K
K
Masserot
A
A
Matichard
F
F
Matone
L
L
Matzner
R A
RA
Mavalvala
N
N
McCarthy
R
R
McClelland
D E
DE
McGuire
S C
SC
McHugh
M
M
McIntyre
G
G
McKechan
D J A
DJ
McKenzie
K
K
Mehmet
M
M
Melatos
A
A
Melissinos
A C
AC
Mendell
G
G
Menéndez
D F
DF
Menzinger
F
F
Mercer
R A
RA
Meshkov
S
S
Messenger
C
C
Meyer
M S
MS
Michel
C
C
Milano
L
L
Miller
J
J
Minelli
J
J
Minenkov
Y
Y
Mino
Y
Y
Mitrofanov
V P
VP
Mitselmakher
G
G
Mittleman
R
R
Miyakawa
O
O
Moe
B
B
Mohan
M
M
Mohanty
S D
SD
Mohapatra
S R P
SR
Moreau
J
J
Moreno
G
G
Morgado
N
N
Morgia
A
A
Morioka
T
T
Mors
K
K
Mosca
S
S
Mossavi
K
K
Mours
B
B
Mowlowry
C
C
Mueller
G
G
Muhammad
D
D
Mühlen
H Zur
HZ
Mukherjee
S
S
Mukhopadhyay
H
H
Mullavey
A
A
Müller-Ebhardt
H
H
Munch
J
J
Murray
P G
PG
Myers
E
E
Myers
J
J
Nash
T
T
Nelson
J
J
Neri
I
I
Newton
G
G
Nishizawa
A
A
Nocera
F
F
Numata
K
K
Ochsner
E
E
O'Dell
J
J
Ogin
G H
GH
O'Reilly
B
B
O'Shaughnessy
R
R
Ottaway
D J
DJ
Ottens
R S
RS
Overmier
H
H
Owen
B J
BJ
Pagliaroli
G
G
Palomba
C
C
Pan
Y
Y
Pankow
C
C
Paoletti
F
F
Papa
M A
MA
Parameshwaraiah
V
V
Pardi
S
S
Pasqualetti
A
A
Passaquieti
R
R
Passuello
D
D
Patel
P
P
Pedraza
M
M
Penn
S
S
Perreca
A
A
Persichetti
G
G
Pichot
M
M
Piergiovanni
F
F
Pierro
V
V
Pinard
L
L
Pinto
I M
IM
Pitkin
M
M
Pletsch
H J
HJ
Plissi
M V
MV
Poggiani
R
R
Postiglione
F
F
Principe
M
M
Prix
R
R
Prodi
G A
GA
Prokhorov
L
L
Punken
O
O
Punturo
M
M
Puppo
P
P
Putten
S van der
Sv
Quetschke
V
V
Raab
F J
FJ
Rabaste
O
O
Rabeling
D S
DS
Radkins
H
H
Raffai
P
P
Raics
Z
Z
Rainer
N
N
Rakhmanov
M
M
Rapagnani
P
P
Raymond
V
V
Re
V
V
Reed
C M
CM
Reed
T
T
Regimbau
T
T
Rehbein
H
H
Reid
S
S
Reitze
D H
DH
Ricci
F
F
Riesen
R
R
Riles
K
K
Rivera
B
B
Roberts
P
P
Robertson
N A
NA
Robinet
F
F
Robinson
C
C
Robinson
E L
EL
Rocchi
A
A
Roddy
S
S
Rolland
L
L
Rollins
J
J
Romano
J D
JD
Romano
R
R
Romie
J H
JH
Röver
C
C
Rowan
S
S
Rüdiger
A
A
Ruggi
P
P
Russell
P
P
Ryan
K
K
Sakata
S
S
Salemi
F
F
Sandberg
V
V
Sannibale
V
V
Santamaría
L
L
Saraf
S
S
Sarin
P
P
Sassolas
B
B
Sathyaprakash
B S
BS
Sato
S
S
Satterthwaite
M
M
Saulson
P R
PR
Savage
R
R
Savov
P
P
Scanlan
M
M
Schilling
R
R
Schnabel
R
R
Schofield
R
R
Schulz
B
B
Schutz
B F
BF
Schwinberg
P
P
Scott
J
J
Scott
S M
SM
Searle
A C
AC
Sears
B
B
Seifert
F
F
Sellers
D
D
Sengupta
A S
AS
Sentenac
D
D
Sergeev
A
A
Shapiro
B
B
Shawhan
P
P
Shoemaker
D H
DH
Sibley
A
A
Siemens
X
X
Sigg
D
D
Sinha
S
S
Sintes
A M
AM
Slagmolen
B J J
BJ
Slutsky
J
J
van der Sluys
M V
MV
Smith
J R
JR
Smith
M R
MR
Smith
N D
ND
Somiya
K
K
Sorazu
B
B
Stein
A
A
Stein
L C
LC
Steplewski
S
S
Stochino
A
A
Stone
R
R
Strain
K A
KA
Strigin
S
S
Stroeer
A
A
Sturani
R
R
Stuver
A L
AL
Summerscales
T Z
TZ
Sun
K-X
KX
Sung
M
M
Sutton
P J
PJ
Swinkels
B L
BL
Szokoly
G P
GP
Talukder
D
D
Tang
L
L
Tanner
D B
DB
Tarabrin
S P
SP
Taylor
J R
JR
Taylor
R
R
Terenzi
R
R
Thacker
J
J
Thorne
K A
KA
Thorne
K S
KS
Thüring
A
A
Tokmakov
K V
KV
Toncelli
A
A
Tonelli
M
M
Torres
C
C
Torrie
C
C
Tournefier
E
E
Travasso
F
F
Traylor
G
G
Trias
M
M
Trummer
J
J
Ugolini
D
D
Ulmen
J
J
Urbanek
K
K
Vahlbruch
H
H
Vajente
G
G
Vallisneri
M
M
Vass
S
S
Vaulin
R
R
Vavoulidis
M
M
Vecchio
A
A
Vedovato
G
G
van Veggel
A A
AA
Veitch
J
J
Veitch
P
P
Veltkamp
C
C
Verkindt
D
D
Vetrano
F
F
Viceré
A
A
Villar
A
A
Vinet
J-Y
JY
Vocca
H
H
Vorvick
C
C
Vyachanin
S P
SP
Waldman
S J
SJ
Wallace
L
L
Ward
H
H
Ward
R L
RL
Was
M
M
Weidner
A
A
Weinert
M
M
Weinstein
A J
AJ
Weiss
R
R
Wen
L
L
Wen
S
S
Wette
K
K
Whelan
J T
JT
Whitcomb
S E
SE
Whiting
B F
BF
Wilkinson
C
C
Willems
P A
PA
Williams
H R
HR
Williams
L
L
Willke
B
B
Wilmut
I
I
Winkelmann
L
L
Winkler
W
W
Wipf
C C
CC
Wiseman
A G
AG
Woan
G
G
Wooley
R
R
Worden
J
J
Wu
W
W
Yakushin
I
I
Yamamoto
H
H
Yan
Z
Z
Yoshida
S
S
Yvert
M
M
Zanolin
M
M
Zhang
J
J
Zhang
L
L
Zhao
C
C
Zotov
N
N
Zucker
M E
ME
Zweizig
J
J
Phys Rev D Part Fields. 1990 Nov 15;42(10):3413-3421
10012742
Phys Rev D Part Fields. 1994 Jul 15;50(2):1157-1160
10017813
Phys Rev Lett. 2006 Jul 14;97(2):021301
16907428
Phys Rev Lett. 2007 Mar 16;98(11):111101
17501038