A systematic review of occupational safety and health business cases.
OBJECTIVE
Business cases are commonly developed as means to rationalize investment. We systematically reviewed 26 reported cases on occupational safety and health (OSH) interventions to assess if health and productivity arguments make a good business case.


METHODS
To be included in the review, studies had to analyze the costs and benefits, including productivity, of an OSH intervention at the enterprise level. We searched Medline and Embase for studies and used Google search in addition. Two reviewers independently selected studies and extracted data. The intervention profitability was calculated in euros (euro in 2008) as the first year's benefits minus the total intervention costs per worker. The payback period was calculated as the intervention costs divided by the first year's benefits.


RESULTS
We found three ex-ante and 23 ex-post cases. In 20 cases, the study design was a before-after comparison without a control group. Generally a 100% reduction of injuries or sickness absence was assumed. In two cases, productivity and quality increases were very large. The main benefit was avoided sick leave. Depreciation or discounting was applied only in a minority of cases. The intervention profitability was negative in seven studies, up to euro 500 per employee in 12 studies and more than euro 500 per employee in seven studies. The payback period was less than half a year for 19 studies. Only a few studies included sensitivity analyses.


CONCLUSIONS
Few ex-ante business cases for management decisions on OSH are reported. Guidelines for reporting and evaluation are needed. Business cases need more sound assumptions on the effectiveness of interventions and should incorporate greater uncertainty into their design. Ex-post evaluation should be based preferably on study designs that control for trends at a time different from that of the intervention.
Verbeek
Jos
J
Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Knowledge Transfer in Occupational Health and Safety Team, Kuopio, Finland. jos.verbeek@ttl.fi
Pulliainen
Marjo
M
Kankaanpää
Eila
E
D003362:Cost-Benefit Analysis; D017598:Efficiency, Organizational; D006302:Health Services Research; D006801:Humans; D009141:Musculoskeletal System / Q000293:injuries; D009784:Occupational Diseases / Q000517:prevention & control; D016272:Occupational Health; D018582:Sick Leave