Reconciling human smoking behavior and machine smoking patterns: implications for understanding smoking behavior and the impact on laboratory studies.
BACKGROUND
Recent Food and Drug Administration legislation enables the mandating of product performance standards for cigarette smoke and the evaluation of manufacturers' health claims for modified tobacco products. Laboratory studies used for these evaluations and also for understanding tobacco smoke toxicology use machines to generate smoke. The goal of this review is to critically evaluate methods to assess human smoking behavior and replicate this in the laboratory.


METHODS
Smoking behavior and smoking machine studies were identified using PubMed and publicly available databases for internal tobacco company documents.


RESULTS
The smoking machine was developed to generate smoke to allow for comparing cigarette tar and nicotine yields. The intent was to infer relative human disease risk, but this concept was flawed because humans tailor their smoking to the product, and chemical yields and toxicologic effects change with different smoking profiles. Although smoking machines also allow for mechanistic assessments of smoking-related diseases, the interpretations also are limited. However, available methods to assess how humans puff could be used to provide better laboratory assessments, but these need to be validated. Separately, the contribution of smoke mouth-holding and inhalation to dose need to be assessed, because these parts of smoking are not captured by the smoking machine. Better comparisons of cigarettes might be done by tailoring human puff profiles to the product based on human studies and comparing results across regimens.


CONCLUSIONS
There are major research gaps that limit the use of smoking machine studies for informing tobacco control regulation and mechanistic studies.
Marian
Catalin
C
Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center, Georgetown University Medical Center, Washington, DC 20057-1465, USA.
O'Connor
Richard J
RJ
Djordjevic
Mirjana V
MV
Rees
Vaughan W
VW
Hatsukami
Dorothy K
DK
Shields
Peter G
PG
D016739:Behavior, Addictive / Q000523:psychology*; D001682:Biological Availability; D006801:Humans; D012106:Research; D012907:Smoking / Q000523:psychology*; D014029:Tobacco Use Disorder / Q000523:psychology*