Patient-based outcome assessment instruments in acupuncture research.
BACKGROUND
Outcome assessment can support the therapeutic process by providing a way to track symptoms and functionality over time, providing insights to clinicians and patients, as well as offering a common language to discuss patient behavior/functioning.


OBJECTIVE
In this article, we examine the patient-based outcome assessment (PBOA) instruments that have been used to determine outcomes in acupuncture clinical research and highlight measures that are feasible, practical, economical, reliable, valid, and responsive to clinical change. The aims of this review were to assess and identify the commonly available PBOA measures, describe a framework for identifying appropriate sets of measures, and address the challenges associated with these measures and acupuncture. Instruments were evaluated in terms of feasibility, practicality, economy, reliability, validity, and responsiveness to clinical change.


METHODS
This study was a systematic review. A total of 582 abstracts were reviewed using PubMed (from inception through April 2009).


RESULTS
A total of 582 citations were identified. After screening of title/abstract, 212 articles were excluded. From the remaining 370 citations, 258 manuscripts identified explicit PBOA; 112 abstracts did not include any PBOA. The five most common PBOA instruments identified were the Visual Analog Scale, Symptom Diary, Numerical Pain Rating Scales, SF-36, and depression scales such as the Beck Depression Inventory.


CONCLUSIONS
The way a questionnaire or scale is administered can have an effect on the outcome. Also, developing and validating outcome measures can be costly and difficult. Therefore, reviewing the literature on existing measures before creating or modifying PBOA instruments can significantly reduce the burden of developing a new measure.
Khorsan
Raheleh
R
Military Medical Research and Integrative Medicine, Samueli Institute, Corona del Mar, CA 92625, USA. rkhorsan@siib.org
York
Alexandra
A
Coulter
Ian D
ID
Wurzman
Rachel
R
Walter
Joan A G
JA
Coeytaux
Remy R
RR
D015670:Acupuncture Therapy; D019937:Diagnostic Techniques and Procedures; D006801:Humans; D017063:Outcome Assessment, Health Care / Q000379:methods*; D012106:Research