Towards universal childhood immunization against chickenpox?
Live attenuated varicella vaccine is available in Canada. The National Advisory Committee on Immunization recommended immunization of healthy susceptible individuals after one year of age. This was endorsed by a National Varicella Consensus Conference, provided that 90% coverage could be ensured. So far only Prince Edward Island has begun universal childhood immunization. Barriers to achieving high childhood vaccine coverage include: the perception that chickenpox is mild in children but severe in both adults and immunocompromised; concern that vaccine field effectiveness will be much lower than observed in pre-licensure efficacy trials; fear that waning immunity may increase adult cases and the associated disease burden; and uncertainty regarding long term morbidity due to vaccine strain reactivation. In fact, chickenpox is usually an uncomplicated illness in otherwise healthy individuals of all ages. Further, with varicella zoster immunoglobulin (VZIG) prophylaxis and acyclovir treatment soon after rash onset, the course in immunocompromised individuals is also usually benign. However, on a population basis, otherwise healthy children with no identifiable risk factors account for 80% to 90% of all chickenpox-associated hospital admissions and 40% to 60% of case fatalities. A more accurate assessment of the relative merits of varicella immunization should contrast the current natural history of disease (90% to 95% infected symptomatically by age 15 years, 15% lifetime risk of a moderate to severe reactivation episode) with the demonstrated vaccine effectiveness of 70% to 86% against any chickenpox, 95% to 100% against moderate to severe illness and significant reduction of frequency and severity of reactivation illness.
Law
B J
BJ
Department of Pediatrics and Child Health, University of Manitoba and Winnipeg Hospital, Winnipeg, Manitoba.